Frankfort J D, Fischer C E, Stansbury D W, McArthur D L, Brown S E, Light R W
Department of Medicine, VA Medical Center, Long Beach, CA 90822.
Chest. 1991 Sep;100(3):792-5. doi: 10.1378/chest.100.3.792.
The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of isocaloric liquid meals with high fat (55 percent) and low carbohydrate (28 percent) content (Pulmocare) to meals with low fat (30 percent) and high carbohydrate (53 percent) content (Ensureplus) on exercise performance in subjects with chronic airflow obstruction (CAO). Twelve stable subjects with CAO (FEV1 = 1.30 +/- 0.47 L) underwent incremental symptom-limited exercise tests 90 minutes following the ingestion of 920 calories of EnsurePlus HN (E), 920 calories of Pulmocare (P), or a noncaloric placebo (C). Tests were performed on three days, in a double-blind randomized fashion. Expired gases were collected continuously and analyzed every 30 seconds. The mean maximal work load after E (81 +/- 24 W) was significantly less than that after P (88 +/- 21 W) or C (88 +/- 24 W). The mean ventilation at exhaustion was similar after E (48 +/- 13 L/min), P (51 +/- 11 L/min), and C (49 +/- 10 L/min). In comparison to C, six of the 12 individuals had a decreased work load following E, while only one had a decreased maximal tolerated work load following P. The results of this study suggest that meals with a higher fat and lower carbohydrate content may be less likely to impair work performance of patients with CAO in the absorptive phase than meals with a lower fat and higher carbohydrate content. These findings may have clinical significance to patients with CAO who complain of postprandial exertional dyspnea.
本研究旨在比较高热量、高脂肪(55%)、低碳水化合物(28%)含量的流质餐(Pulmocare)与低脂肪(30%)、高碳水化合物(53%)含量的流质餐(Ensureplus)对慢性气流阻塞(CAO)患者运动表现的影响。12名病情稳定的CAO患者(FEV1 = 1.30 +/- 0.47升)在摄入920卡路里的EnsurePlus HN(E组)、920卡路里的Pulmocare(P组)或无热量安慰剂(C组)90分钟后,进行递增症状限制运动测试。测试以双盲随机方式在三天内进行。持续收集呼出气体,每30秒分析一次。E组后的平均最大工作负荷(81 +/- 24瓦)显著低于P组(88 +/- 21瓦)或C组(88 +/- 24瓦)。E组(48 +/- 13升/分钟)、P组(51 +/- 11升/分钟)和C组(49 +/- 10升/分钟)力竭时的平均通气量相似。与C组相比,12名个体中有6名在摄入E组餐食后工作负荷降低,而摄入P组餐食后只有1名个体的最大耐受工作负荷降低。本研究结果表明,与低脂肪、高碳水化合物含量的餐食相比,高脂肪、低碳水化合物含量的餐食在吸收阶段可能不太可能损害CAO患者的工作表现。这些发现可能对抱怨餐后运动性呼吸困难的CAO患者具有临床意义。