Malik Marek, Hnatkova Katerina, Schmidt Anna, Smetana Peter
St. Paul's Cardiac Electrophysiology, London, England.
Heart Rhythm. 2008 Oct;5(10):1424-31. doi: 10.1016/j.hrthm.2008.07.023. Epub 2008 Jul 26.
Circadian QTc changes have been reported, with conflicting results. Spontaneous QTc variability is important for pharmaceutical cardiac safety studies.
The purpose of this study was to investigate QTc variability in accurately measured and heart-rate corrected daytime data of healthy subjects.
Continuous 12-lead ECGs were recorded in 53 healthy volunteers. For each recording, approximately 320 ECG samples of 10 seconds were obtained throughout the daytime period, all preceded by stable heart rates. In each ECG sample, QT interval was measured on superimposed 12 leads by two independent cardiologists and reconciled. Four RR-interval expressions were used: (a) average of the first three RR of the ECG sample, (b) RR average of the 10-second sample, (c) average of RR intervals in a 2-minute history, and (d) RR intervals of an independently established individual QT/RR hysteresis profile. For all RR-interval expressions, QT intervals were corrected using the Fridericia formula and individually optimized curvature correction. QTc variability was measured by intraindividual QTc standard deviations.
With Fridericia correction and the RR expressions (a) to (d), QTc variability obtained was (a) 9.45 +/- 1.70 ms, (b) 7.80 +/- 1.48 ms, (c) 6.37 +/- 1.64 ms, and (d) 5.81 +/- 1.75 ms. With individualized correction, QTc variability was (a) 8.16 +/- 1.71 ms, (b) 6.71 +/- 1.41 ms, (c) 5.22 +/- 1.13 ms, and (d) 4.56 +/- 1.18 ms. All differences (b) vs (a), (c) vs (b), and (d) vs (c) were highly statistically significant (P <10(-12) in all cases).
Previously reported large QTc variability largely results from methodologic imprecision. Little QTc variability is present in daytime recordings of healthy subjects. Consequently, QT-related pharmaceutical cardiac safety studies can be made smaller without decreasing their power.
已有昼夜QTc变化的报道,但结果相互矛盾。自发性QTc变异性对药物心脏安全性研究很重要。
本研究旨在调查健康受试者经准确测量和心率校正的日间数据中的QTc变异性。
对53名健康志愿者进行连续12导联心电图记录。每次记录时,在整个白天时段获取约320个10秒的心电图样本,所有样本之前心率均稳定。在每个心电图样本中,由两名独立的心脏病专家在叠加的12导联上测量QT间期并进行核对。使用了四种RR间期表达式:(a)心电图样本前三个RR的平均值,(b)10秒样本的RR平均值,(c)2分钟历史记录中RR间期的平均值,以及(d)独立建立的个体QT/RR滞后曲线的RR间期。对于所有RR间期表达式,使用弗里德里西亚公式校正QT间期并进行个体优化的曲率校正。通过个体内QTc标准差测量QTc变异性。
采用弗里德里西亚校正和RR表达式(a)至(d)时,获得的QTc变异性分别为:(a)9.45±1.70毫秒,(b)7.80±1.48毫秒,(c)6.37±1.64毫秒,(d)5.81±1.75毫秒。采用个体化校正时,QTc变异性分别为:(a)8.16±1.71毫秒,(b)6.71±1.41毫秒,(c)5.22±1.13毫秒,(d)4.56±1.18毫秒。所有(b)与(a)、(c)与(b)以及(d)与(c)的差异均具有高度统计学意义(所有情况下P<10⁻¹²)。
先前报道的较大QTc变异性很大程度上源于方法学的不精确性。健康受试者的日间记录中QTc变异性很小。因此,与QT相关的药物心脏安全性研究可以规模更小而不降低其效能。