Collaer Marcia L, Brook Charles G D, Conway Gerard S, Hindmarsh Peter C, Hines Melissa
Department of Psychology & Program in Neuroscience, Middlebury College, Middlebury, VT 05753, USA.
University College London, UK.
Psychoneuroendocrinology. 2009 Feb;34(2):249-258. doi: 10.1016/j.psyneuen.2008.09.007. Epub 2008 Oct 19.
This study investigated early androgen influence on the development of human motor and visuomotor characteristics. Participants, ages 12-45 years, were individuals with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH), a disorder causing increased adrenal androgen production before birth (40 females, 29 males) and their unaffected relatives (29 females, 30 males). We investigated grip strength and visuomotor targeting tasks on which males generally outperform females, and fine motor pegboard tasks on which females generally outperform males. Physical characteristics (height and weight) were measured to explore whether body parameters could explain differences in motor skills. Females with CAH were stronger and showed better targeting than unaffected females and showed reduced fine visuomotor skill on one pegboard measure, with no difference on the other. Males with CAH were weaker than unaffected males in grip strength but did not differ on the targeting or pegboard measures. Correction for body size could not explain the findings for females, but suggests that the reduced strength of males with CAH may relate to their smaller stature. Further, the targeting advantage in females with CAH persisted following adjustment for their greater strength. Results in females support the hypothesis that androgen may masculinize, or promote, certain motor characteristics at which males excel, and contribute to defeminization of certain fine motor characteristics at which females excel. Thus, these data suggest that organizational effects of androgens on behavior during prenatal life may extend to motor characteristics and may contribute to general sex differences in motor-related behaviors; however, alternative explanations based on activational influences of androgen or altered experiential factors cannot be excluded without further study.
本研究调查了早期雄激素对人类运动及视觉运动特征发育的影响。参与者年龄在12至45岁之间,包括先天性肾上腺皮质增生症(CAH)患者(一种导致出生前肾上腺雄激素分泌增加的疾病,40名女性,29名男性)及其未受影响的亲属(29名女性,30名男性)。我们研究了握力和视觉运动目标任务(在这些任务上男性通常表现优于女性)以及精细运动插板任务(在这些任务上女性通常表现优于男性)。测量了身体特征(身高和体重)以探究身体参数是否能解释运动技能的差异。患有CAH的女性比未受影响的女性更强壮,在目标任务上表现更好,并且在一项插板测量中精细视觉运动技能有所下降,在另一项测量中则无差异。患有CAH的男性在握力方面比未受影响的男性更弱,但在目标任务或插板测量上没有差异。对身体大小进行校正无法解释女性的研究结果,但表明患有CAH的男性力量减弱可能与其身材较小有关。此外,患有CAH的女性在力量更大的情况下,其目标任务优势依然存在。女性的研究结果支持了以下假设:雄激素可能使某些男性擅长的运动特征男性化或促进其发展,并导致某些女性擅长的精细运动特征女性化减弱。因此,这些数据表明,雄激素在产前生活中对行为的组织效应可能延伸至运动特征,并可能导致运动相关行为的总体性别差异;然而,在没有进一步研究的情况下,不能排除基于雄激素的激活影响或改变的经验因素的其他解释。