Hommel Kevin A, Mackner Laura M, Denson Lee A, Crandall Wallace V
Center for the Promotion of Treatment Adherence and Self-Management, Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, OH 45229-3039, USA.
J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. 2008 Nov;47(5):526-43. doi: 10.1097/MPG.0b013e318175dda1.
To review and critically evaluate the extant research pertaining to adherence in pediatric gastroenterological diseases, particularly inflammatory bowel disease and celiac disease, and to provide recommendations for future research development.
A literature search with no date restriction was conducted using PubMed and PsychInfo electronic databases and bibliographies of relevant articles.
Adherence rates in inflammatory bowel disease and celiac disease range considerably from 16% to 62% and 5% to 70%, respectively, across treatments and assessment method; nonadherence frequency was generally not reported. Measures used to assess adherence included self-report, interview, diet record, and bioassay methods, and each measure demonstrated strengths and limitations. Limited evidence suggests that adherence in both disease populations is related to patient and family behavioral factors and that nonadherence is related to poor disease outcome. Treatment outcome research for nonadherence is scant in the current literature.
Future research should focus on refining assessment method, examining adherence and concomitant behavioral factors longitudinally, testing theoretical models of adherence, and developing efficacious treatments for nonadherence.
回顾并严格评估有关小儿胃肠疾病,特别是炎症性肠病和乳糜泻的依从性的现有研究,并为未来的研究发展提供建议。
使用PubMed和PsychInfo电子数据库以及相关文章的参考文献进行无日期限制的文献检索。
炎症性肠病和乳糜泻的依从率在不同治疗方法和评估方法之间差异很大,分别为16%至62%和5%至70%;一般未报告不依从的频率。用于评估依从性的方法包括自我报告、访谈、饮食记录和生物测定方法,每种方法都有其优点和局限性。有限的证据表明,这两种疾病人群的依从性与患者和家庭行为因素有关,而不依从与不良疾病结局有关。目前文献中关于不依从的治疗结局研究很少。
未来的研究应集中在完善评估方法、纵向研究依从性及相关行为因素、测试依从性理论模型以及开发针对不依从的有效治疗方法上。