Roberts Dorothy E
Northwestern University School of Law, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
Child Welfare. 2008;87(2):125-50.
This article examines the community-level impact of concentrated child welfare agency involvement in African American neighborhoods. Based on interviews of 25 African American women in a Chicago neighborhood, the study found that residents were aware of intense agency involvement in their neighborhood and identified profound effects on social relationships including interference with parental authority, damage to children's ability to form social relationships, and distrust among neighbors. The study also discovered a tension between respondents' identification of adverse consequences of concentrated state supervision for family and community relationships and neighborhood reliance on agency involvement for needed financial support. The author discusses the implications of these findings for a new research paradigm aimed at understanding the community-level effects of racial disproportionality.
本文探讨了儿童福利机构在非裔美国人社区的集中干预对社区层面的影响。基于对芝加哥一个社区25名非裔美国女性的访谈,该研究发现居民们意识到机构在他们社区的大量干预,并指出这对社会关系产生了深远影响,包括对家长权威的干扰、损害儿童建立社会关系的能力以及邻里间的不信任。该研究还发现,受访者一方面认定国家的集中监管对家庭和社区关系有负面影响,另一方面社区又依赖机构的干预来获取所需的经济支持,这两者之间存在矛盾。作者讨论了这些研究结果对于旨在理解种族不均衡在社区层面影响的新研究范式的意义。