Calegaro J U, Machado J, DE Paula J C, DE Almeida J S C, Casulari L A
Nuclear Medicine Service of the Hospital de Base do Distrito Federal (HBDF), Brasília, DF.
Haemophilia. 2009 Jan;15(1):240-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2516.2008.01908.x. Epub 2008 Oct 30.
The aim is to evaluate the efficiency of the treatment with 153-samarium hydroxyapatite (153-Sm-HA) in haemophilic arthropathy. Thirty-one patients (30 males) with ages ranging from 8 to 34 years (average age = 20.6 years) were treated with fixed intra-articular dose of 185 MBq (5 mCi) and divided into two groups: infantile-juvenile (13 patients with up to 18 years of age, an average age of 12.7 years and arthropathy evolution of 7.8 years), and adult (18 patients older than 18 years, an average age of 24 years and arthropathy evolution of 18.7 years). The clinical evaluation before and after 1 year of synovectomy used the following criteria: subjective (pain through visual scale, articulation inspection), objective (articular movement through flexion level, sensitivity to palpation and leakage through joint circumference), reduction on the use of the coagulation factor, number of haemarthrosis, and the occurrence of adverse effects. The results were classified as: 1, good (remission from 70% to 100% of manifestations); 2, moderate (remission from 40% to 69%); and 3, poor (remission from 0% to 39%). Seventy-eight joints were tested: 15 knees, 36 elbows, 24 ankles, 1 shoulder and 2 hips. Early scintigraphic (1-2 h) and late scintigraphic (24-72 h) studies were performed after synoviorthesis. The cost of the procedure per joint was also estimated. No significant difference in the synoviorthesis result between groups was observed. The results were good for 75% of elbows, 87.5% of ankles and 40% of knees; the reduction in haemarthrosis and use of the coagulation factor was respectively 78% and 80% for elbows, 82% and 85% for ankles and 30% and 35% for knees. Four cases of reactional synovitis were observed in the 31 patients. The scintigraphic control showed homogeneous distribution of the material with no articular escape. The use of 153 Sm-HA in the treatment of the haemophilic arthropathy is effective for intermediate-size joints (elbows and ankles), but less effective for knees. Moreover, this treatment presents an excellent safety profile and accessible cost.
目的是评估153 - 钐羟基磷灰石(153 - Sm - HA)治疗血友病性关节病的疗效。31例患者(30例男性),年龄8至34岁(平均年龄 = 20.6岁),接受固定关节内剂量185 MBq(5 mCi)的治疗,并分为两组:婴幼儿 - 青少年组(13例年龄在18岁及以下,平均年龄12.7岁,关节病病程7.8年)和成人组(18例年龄大于18岁,平均年龄24岁,关节病病程18.7年)。滑膜切除术后1年前后的临床评估采用以下标准:主观标准(通过视觉量表评估疼痛、关节检查)、客观标准(通过屈曲程度评估关节活动、触诊敏感性以及通过关节周长评估渗漏情况)、凝血因子使用量的减少、关节积血次数以及不良反应的发生情况。结果分为:1级,良好(70%至100%的症状缓解);2级,中等(40%至69%的症状缓解);3级,差(0%至39%的症状缓解)。共检测了78个关节:15个膝关节、36个肘关节、24个踝关节、1个肩关节和2个髋关节。滑膜切除术后进行了早期闪烁显像(1 - 2小时)和晚期闪烁显像(24 - 72小时)研究。还估算了每个关节的治疗费用。两组间滑膜切除术结果无显著差异。肘关节的结果良好率为75%,踝关节为87.5%,膝关节为40%;肘关节关节积血和凝血因子使用量的减少率分别为78%和80%,踝关节为82%和85%,膝关节为30%和35%。31例患者中观察到4例反应性滑膜炎。闪烁显像检查显示材料分布均匀,无关节渗漏。153 Sm - HA用于治疗血友病性关节病对中等大小关节(肘关节和踝关节)有效,但对膝关节效果较差。此外,这种治疗具有良好的安全性和可承受的成本。