Hirsch L J, Arif H, Nahm E A, Buchsbaum R, Resor S R, Bazil C W
Associate Clinical Comprehensive Epilepsy Center, Columbia University, Neurological Institute, New York, NY 10032, USA.
Neurology. 2008 Nov 4;71(19):1527-34. doi: 10.1212/01.wnl.0000334295.50403.4c.
To determine rates of cross-sensitivity of rash among commonly used antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) in patients with epilepsy.
The incidence of AED-related rash was determined in 1875 outpatients (> or =12 years), taking carbamazepine (CBZ), clobazam (CLB), felbamate (FBM), gabapentin (GBP), levetiracetam (LEV), lamotrigine (LTG), oxcarbazepine (OXC), phenobarbital (PB), phenytoin (PHT), primidone (PRM), tiagabine (TGB), topiramate (TPM), vigabatrin (VGB), valproic acid (VPA), or zonisamide (ZNS). We compared rates of rash for each AED in patients with vs those without a rash to 1) another specific AED; 2) any other AED; 3) any two other AEDs; and 4) any non-epilepsy medication.
A total of 14.3% (269/1,875) of patients had a rash attributed to at least one AED; 2.8% had a rash to two or more AEDs. Of patients who had a rash to CBZ and were also prescribed PHT (n = 59), 57.6% had a rash to PHT (abbreviated as CBZ --> PHT: 57.6%); of patients who had a rash to PHT and were also prescribed CBZ (n = 81), rate of rash was 42% (i.e., PHT --> CBZ: 42%). Other results: CBZ --> LTG: 20% (n = 50); LTG --> CBZ: 26.3% (n = 38); CBZ --> OXC: 33% (n = 15); OXC --> CBZ: 71.4% (n = 7); CBZ --> PB: 26.7% (n = 30); PB --> CBZ: 66.7% (n = 12); LTG --> PHT: 38.9% (n = 36); PHT --> LTG: 18.9% (n = 74); PB --> PHT: 53.3% (n = 15); PHT --> PB: 19.5% (n = 41); OXC --> LTG: 37.5% (n = 8); LTG --> OXC: 20% (n = 15). There was evidence of specific cross-sensitivity between CBZ and PHT, and between CBZ and PB.
Cross-sensitivity rates between certain antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) are high, especially when involving carbamazepine and phenytoin. Specific cross-sensitivity rates provided here may be useful for AED selection and counseling in individual patients.
确定癫痫患者中常用抗癫痫药物(AEDs)之间皮疹的交叉敏感率。
确定了1875例年龄≥12岁的门诊患者中与AED相关皮疹的发生率,这些患者正在服用卡马西平(CBZ)、氯巴占(CLB)、非氨酯(FBM)、加巴喷丁(GBP)、左乙拉西坦(LEV)、拉莫三嗪(LTG)、奥卡西平(OXC)、苯巴比妥(PB)、苯妥英(PHT)、扑米酮(PRM)、噻加宾(TGB)、托吡酯(TPM)、氨己烯酸(VGB)、丙戊酸(VPA)或唑尼沙胺(ZNS)。我们比较了有皮疹患者与无皮疹患者中每种AED与以下情况的皮疹发生率:1)另一种特定AED;2)任何其他AED;3)任何另外两种AED;4)任何非癫痫药物。
共有14.3%(269/1875)的患者出现了至少一种AED引起的皮疹;2.8%的患者对两种或更多种AED出现皮疹。在对CBZ出现皮疹且也服用PHT的患者(n = 59)中,57.6%的患者对PHT出现皮疹(简称为CBZ→PHT:57.6%);在对PHT出现皮疹且也服用CBZ的患者(n = 81)中,皮疹发生率为42%(即PHT→CBZ:42%)。其他结果:CBZ→LTG:20%(n = 50);LTG→CBZ:26.3%(n = 38);CBZ→OXC:33%(n = 15);OXC→CBZ:71.4%(n = 7);CBZ→PB:26.7%(n = 30);PB→CBZ:66.7%(n = 12);LTG→PHT:38.9%(n = 36);PHT→LTG:18.9%(n = 74);PB→PHT:53.3%(n = 15);PHT→PB:19.5%(n = 41)。有证据表明CBZ与PHT之间以及CBZ与PB之间存在特定的交叉敏感性。
某些抗癫痫药物(AEDs)之间的交叉敏感率很高,尤其是涉及卡马西平和苯妥英时。此处提供的特定交叉敏感率可能有助于个体患者的AED选择和咨询。