Doeswijk T G, Keesman K J
Systems and Control Group, Wageningen University, P.O. Box 17, 6700 AA Wageningen, The Netherlands.
Water Res. 2009 Jan;43(1):107-16. doi: 10.1016/j.watres.2008.10.019. Epub 2008 Oct 18.
For rational biokinetic functions such as the Michaelis-Menten equation, in general, a nonlinear least-squares method is a good estimator. However, a major drawback of a nonlinear least-squares estimator is that it can end up in a local minimum. Rearranging and linearizing rational biokinetic functions for parameter estimation is common practice (e.g. Lineweaver-Burk linearization). By rearranging, however, the error is distorted. In addition, the rearranged model frequently leads to a so-called 'errors-in-variables' estimation problem. Applying the ordinary least squares (OLS) method to the linearly reparameterized function ensures a global minimum, but its estimates become biased if the regression variables contain errors and thus bias compensation is needed. Therefore, in this paper, a bias compensated total least squares (CTLS) method, which as OLS is a direct method, is proposed to solve the estimation problem. The applicability of a general linear reparameterization procedure and the advances of CTLS over ordinary least squares and nonlinear least squares approaches are shown by two simulation examples. The examples contain Michaelis-Menten kinetics and enzyme kinetics with substrate inhibition. Furthermore, CTLS is demonstrated with real data of an activated sludge experiment. It is concluded that for rational biokinetic models CTLS is a powerful alternative to the existing least-squares methods.
对于诸如米氏方程这样的合理生物动力学函数,一般来说,非线性最小二乘法是一种很好的估计方法。然而,非线性最小二乘估计器的一个主要缺点是它可能最终陷入局部最小值。为了进行参数估计,对合理生物动力学函数进行重新排列和线性化是常见的做法(例如Lineweaver - Burk线性化)。然而,通过重新排列,误差会被扭曲。此外,重新排列后的模型经常会导致所谓的“变量误差”估计问题。将普通最小二乘法(OLS)应用于线性重新参数化的函数可确保全局最小值,但如果回归变量包含误差,其估计会产生偏差,因此需要进行偏差补偿。因此,在本文中,提出了一种偏差补偿总体最小二乘法(CTLS),它与OLS一样是一种直接方法,用于解决估计问题。通过两个模拟示例展示了一般线性重新参数化过程的适用性以及CTLS相对于普通最小二乘法和非线性最小二乘法的优势。这些示例包含米氏动力学和具有底物抑制的酶动力学。此外,用活性污泥实验的实际数据对CTLS进行了验证。得出的结论是,对于合理的生物动力学模型,CTLS是现有最小二乘法的有力替代方法。