Awan Mohammad Sohail, Iqbal Moghira
Department of Surgery, Section of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi, Pakistan.
Ear Nose Throat J. 2008 Nov;87(11):624-7.
The once-common practice of packing the nose after septoplasty was based on a desire to prevent postoperative complications such as bleeding, septal hematoma, and adhesion formation. However, it was since found that not only is nasal packing ineffective in this regard, it can actually cause these complications. Although the consensus in the world literature is that packing should be avoided, to the best of our knowledge, no truly randomized study has been undertaken in Southwest Asia upon which to justify this recommendation here. Therefore, we conducted a prospective randomized comparison of the incidence of a variety of postoperative signs and symptoms in 88 patients, 15 years of age and older, who did (n = 44) and did not (n = 44) undergo nasal packing following septoplasty. We found that the patients who underwent packing experienced significantly more postoperative pain, headache, epiphora, dysphagia, and sleep disturbance on the night of surgery. Oral and nasal examinations 7 days postoperatively revealed no significant difference between the two groups in the incidence of bleeding, septal hematoma, adhesion formation, and local infection. Finally, the packing group reported a moderate to high level of pain during removal of the packing. Our findings confirm that nasal packing after septoplasty is not only unnecessary, it is actually a source of patient discomfort and other signs and symptoms.
鼻中隔成形术后填塞鼻腔这一曾经常见的做法,是基于预防术后并发症(如出血、鼻中隔血肿和粘连形成)的愿望。然而,后来发现鼻腔填塞不仅在这方面无效,实际上还会引发这些并发症。尽管世界文献的共识是应避免填塞,但据我们所知,在西南亚地区尚未进行过真正的随机研究来证明在此处提出这一建议的合理性。因此,我们对88名15岁及以上行鼻中隔成形术后进行(n = 44)和未进行(n = 44)鼻腔填塞的患者术后各种体征和症状的发生率进行了前瞻性随机比较。我们发现,进行填塞的患者在术后当晚经历的疼痛、头痛、溢泪、吞咽困难和睡眠障碍明显更多。术后7天的口腔和鼻腔检查显示,两组在出血、鼻中隔血肿、粘连形成和局部感染的发生率方面无显著差异。最后,填塞组在取出填塞物时报告了中度至高度的疼痛。我们的研究结果证实,鼻中隔成形术后鼻腔填塞不仅没有必要,实际上还是患者不适及其他体征和症状的一个来源。