Chow Edward, Abdolell Mohamed, Panzarella Tony, Harris Kristin, Bezjak Andrea, Warde Padraig, Tannock Ian
Department of Radiation Oncology, Odette Cancer Centre, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, 2075 Bayview Ave, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M4N 3M5.
J Clin Oncol. 2008 Dec 20;26(36):5863-9. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2008.17.1363. Epub 2008 Nov 17.
To derive and validate a simple predictive model for survival of patients with metastatic cancer attending a palliative radiotherapy clinic.
We described previously a model predicting survival of patients referred for palliative radiotherapy using six prognostic factors: primary cancer site, site of metastases, Karnofsky performance score (KPS), and the fatigue, appetite, and shortness of breath subscales from the Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale. Here we simplified the model to include only three factors: primary cancer site, site of metastases, and KPS. Each factor was assigned a value proportional to its prognostic weight, and the weighted scores for each patient were summed to obtain a survival prediction score (SPS). Patients were also grouped according to their number of risk factors (NRF): nonbreast cancer, metastases other than bone, and KPS < or = 60. The three- and six- variable models were evaluated for their ability to predict survival in patients referred during a different time period and of those referred to a different cancer center.
A training set of 395 patients, a temporal validation set of 445 patients, and an external validation set of 467 patients were used. The ability of the three- and six-variable models to separate patients into three prognostic groups and to predict their survival was similar using both SPS and NRF methods in the training, temporal, and external validation data sets. There was no statistically significant difference in the performance of the models.
The three-variable NRF model is preferred because of its relative simplicity.
推导并验证一个用于预测姑息性放疗门诊转移性癌症患者生存情况的简单预测模型。
我们之前描述了一个使用六个预后因素预测接受姑息性放疗患者生存情况的模型,这六个因素为:原发癌部位、转移部位、卡诺夫斯基功能状态评分(KPS)以及埃德蒙顿症状评估量表中的疲劳、食欲和呼吸急促子量表。在此,我们将模型简化为仅包含三个因素:原发癌部位、转移部位和KPS。每个因素被赋予与其预后权重成比例的值,将每位患者的加权分数相加得到生存预测分数(SPS)。患者还根据其危险因素数量(NRF)进行分组:非乳腺癌、非骨转移以及KPS≤60。对三变量模型和六变量模型在不同时间段转诊患者以及转诊至不同癌症中心患者中的生存预测能力进行评估。
使用了一个包含395例患者的训练集、一个包含445例患者的时间验证集以及一个包含467例患者的外部验证集。在训练集、时间验证集和外部验证数据集中,使用SPS和NRF方法时,三变量模型和六变量模型将患者分为三个预后组并预测其生存的能力相似。模型性能无统计学显著差异。
由于其相对简单性,三变量NRF模型更受青睐。