Nair Raghu Ram K, Rajan Balakrishnan, Akiba Suminori, Jayalekshmi P, Nair M Krishnan, Gangadharan P, Koga Taeko, Morishima Hiroshige, Nakamura Seiichi, Sugahara Tsutomu
Regional Cancer Center, Trivandrum, Kerala, India.
Health Phys. 2009 Jan;96(1):55-66. doi: 10.1097/01.HP.0000327646.54923.11.
The coastal belt of Karunagappally, Kerala, India, is known for high background radiation (HBR) from thorium-containing monazite sand. In coastal panchayats, median outdoor radiation levels are more than 4 mGy y-1 and, in certain locations on the coast, it is as high as 70 mGy y-1. Although HBR has been repeatedly shown to increase the frequency of chromosome aberrations in the circulating lymphocytes of exposed persons, its carcinogenic effect is still unproven. A cohort of all 385,103 residents in Karunagappally was established in the 1990's to evaluate health effects of HBR. Based on radiation level measurements, a radiation subcohort consisting of 173,067 residents was chosen. Cancer incidence in this subcohort aged 30-84 y (N = 69,958) was analyzed. Cumulative radiation dose for each individual was estimated based on outdoor and indoor dosimetry of each household, taking into account sex- and age-specific house occupancy factors. Following 69,958 residents for 10.5 years on average, 736,586 person-years of observation were accumulated and 1,379 cancer cases including 30 cases of leukemia were identified by the end of 2005. Poisson regression analysis of cohort data, stratified by sex, attained age, follow-up interval, socio-demographic factors and bidi smoking, showed no excess cancer risk from exposure to terrestrial gamma radiation. The excess relative risk of cancer excluding leukemia was estimated to be -0.13 Gy-1 (95% CI: -0.58, 0.46). In site-specific analysis, no cancer site was significantly related to cumulative radiation dose. Leukemia was not significantly related to HBR, either. Although the statistical power of the study might not be adequate due to the low dose, our cancer incidence study, together with previously reported cancer mortality studies in the HBR area of Yangjiang, China, suggests it is unlikely that estimates of risk at low doses are substantially greater than currently believed.
印度喀拉拉邦卡鲁纳加帕利的沿海地带,因含钍独居石砂产生的高本底辐射(HBR)而闻名。在沿海行政区,室外辐射水平中位数超过4 mGy·y⁻¹,在海岸的某些地点,该数值高达70 mGy·y⁻¹。尽管高本底辐射已多次表明会增加受照者循环淋巴细胞中染色体畸变的频率,但其致癌作用仍未得到证实。20世纪90年代建立了卡鲁纳加帕利所有385,103名居民的队列,以评估高本底辐射对健康的影响。根据辐射水平测量结果,选取了由173,067名居民组成的辐射亚队列。分析了该年龄在30 - 84岁的亚队列(N = 69,958)中的癌症发病率。根据每户的室外和室内剂量测定,并考虑性别和年龄特异性的房屋居住因素,估算了每个人的累积辐射剂量。对69,958名居民平均随访10.5年,累计观察人年数达736,586人年,到2005年底共识别出1379例癌症病例,其中包括30例白血病病例。对队列数据进行按性别、达到年龄、随访间隔、社会人口学因素和双向吸烟分层的泊松回归分析,结果显示,暴露于陆地伽马辐射并未增加患癌风险。排除白血病后的癌症超额相对风险估计为-0.13 Gy⁻¹(95%可信区间:-0.58, 0.46)。在特定部位分析中,没有任何癌症部位与累积辐射剂量显著相关。白血病也与高本底辐射无显著关联。尽管由于剂量较低,该研究的统计效能可能不足,但我们的癌症发病率研究,连同之前在中国阳江高本底辐射地区报道的癌症死亡率研究表明,低剂量风险估计值大幅高于目前所认为的情况不太可能。