Shinoura Nobusada, Yoshida Mizuho, Yamada Ryoji, Tabei Yusuke, Saito Kuniaki, Suzuki Yuichi, Takayama Yoshihiro, Yagi Kazuo
Department of Neurosurgery, Komagome Metropolitan Hospital, 3-18-22 Hon-Komagome, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113-8677, Japan.
J Clin Neurosci. 2009 Feb;16(2):188-94. doi: 10.1016/j.jocn.2008.02.013. Epub 2008 Dec 13.
Resection of brain tumors in the primary motor area (M1) is difficult to achieve without adversely affecting motor function. Between November 2003 and November 2006, 16 patients with 18 brain tumors involving the M1 (11 metastatic, 6 gliomas, 1 cavernous angioma) underwent craniotomy and awake surgery with continuous motor testing at our hospital. Patients were classified as either type A (9 patients), indicating that motor tracts ran in close proximity to the brain tumors, or type B (7 patients), indicating that motor tracts ran distant to the tumor. The relationship between the extent of resection and post-operative motor function was subsequently evaluated. In 17 out of 18 cases, final post-operative motor function was either preserved or improved relative to pre-operative levels, although transient deterioration of motor function and partial removal of the tumor were observed in 7 and 8 cases, respectively. The remaining patients experienced slight deterioration in motor function of the upper extremities. All type A patients experienced suboptimal outcomes, involving transient or permanent deterioration of motor function after surgery or only partial removal of the tumor. By contrast, most type B patients experienced good outcomes (no deterioration of motor function and gross total removal of the tumor). In conclusion, awake surgery with continuous motor testing allowed for resection of brain tumors in the M1 and preservation of motor function, although the patients in whom motor tracts ran in close proximity to the tumors experienced suboptimal outcomes.
在不影响运动功能的情况下,切除位于初级运动区(M1)的脑肿瘤是很难实现的。2003年11月至2006年11月期间,我院对16例患有18个累及M1的脑肿瘤(11个转移瘤、6个胶质瘤、1个海绵状血管瘤)的患者进行了开颅手术及术中唤醒手术,并持续进行运动功能测试。患者被分为A组(9例),即运动传导束紧邻脑肿瘤;或B组(7例),即运动传导束远离肿瘤。随后评估了切除范围与术后运动功能之间的关系。在18例中的17例中,术后最终运动功能相对于术前水平得以保留或改善,不过分别有7例和8例出现了运动功能短暂恶化及肿瘤部分切除的情况。其余患者上肢运动功能出现轻微恶化。所有A组患者的手术效果均不理想,包括术后运动功能短暂或永久性恶化,或仅实现了肿瘤部分切除。相比之下,大多数B组患者手术效果良好(运动功能未恶化且肿瘤全切)。总之,术中唤醒手术及持续运动功能测试能够实现M1区脑肿瘤的切除并保留运动功能,尽管运动传导束紧邻肿瘤的患者手术效果不理想。