Ayalon Liat
School of Social Work, Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan, Israel.
Am J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2009 Jan;17(1):65-74. doi: 10.1097/JGP.0b013e31818cd3d3.
To evaluate public opinion about participation in Alzheimer disease (AD) research and willingness to have a proxy-informed consent.
Cross-sectional.
A national survey of community-dwelling adults over the age of 50 and their spouse of any age.
The 2006 wave of the Health and Retirement Study (N = 1,517).
Willingness to participate in one of four possible research scenarios and to have a proxy-informed consent for AD research.
Overall, 65.8% agreed to participate in AD research and 70.7% agreed to proxy-informed consent. Relative to a minimal benefit and moderate risk scenario, participants were more likely to favor participation in a moderate benefit and minimal risk scenario and less likely to endorse a minimal benefit and severe risk scenario. Those agreeing to participate in the study were more likely to agree to proxy consent and to give leeway to a research proxy to go against their will.
Most participants view AD research favorably and are agreeable toward participating in such research as well as toward having a research proxy. Participants are able to distinguish between studies of different levels of benefit and risk. Nevertheless, over 50% agreed to a study of minimal benefit and severe risk. Researchers and clinicians should be aware that those less agreeable toward AD research are less interested in having a research proxy.
评估公众对参与阿尔茨海默病(AD)研究的看法以及对代理知情同意的意愿。
横断面研究。
对50岁以上社区居住成年人及其任何年龄的配偶进行全国性调查。
2006年健康与退休研究浪潮(N = 1517)。
参与四种可能研究场景之一的意愿以及对AD研究进行代理知情同意的意愿。
总体而言,65.8%的人同意参与AD研究,70.7%的人同意代理知情同意。相对于最小获益和中度风险场景,参与者更倾向于参与中度获益和最小风险场景,而不太可能认可最小获益和严重风险场景。同意参与研究的人更有可能同意代理同意,并给研究代理人违背其意愿的余地。
大多数参与者对AD研究持积极看法,愿意参与此类研究以及接受研究代理人。参与者能够区分不同获益和风险水平的研究。然而,超过50%的人同意参与最小获益和严重风险的研究。研究人员和临床医生应意识到,那些对AD研究不太赞同的人对研究代理人也不太感兴趣。