Divakala K C, Chiba L I, Kamalakar R B, Rodning S P, Welles E G, Cummins K A, Swann J, Cespedes F, Payne R L
Department of Animal Sciences, College of Agriculture, Auburn University, Auburn, AL 36849, USA.
J Anim Sci. 2009 Apr;87(4):1270-81. doi: 10.2527/jas.2008-1121. Epub 2008 Dec 19.
The objective of this study was to determine the possibility of replacing soybean meal (SBM) in finisher pig diets completely with hydrolyzed feather meal (FM). Forty-five gilts and 45 castrated males (57.8+/-0.8 kg of BW; 3 gilts or 3 castrated males/pen) were randomly assigned to 5 finisher-1 diets with 6 pens per diet. At an average pen BW of 81.0+/-1.4 kg, pigs were offered finisher-2 diets. Corn-SBM, finisher-1 and finisher-2 positive control (PC) diets were formulated to contain 6.1 and 4.7 g of apparent ileal digestible (AID) Lys/kg, respectively. Corn-FM negative control (NC) diets were formulated to be iso-N to the PC diets. The NC diets were supplemented with Lys and Trp (NRC; NC + Lys and Trp) to alleviate apparent deficiencies based on AID AA in FM reported by the 1998 NRC. In addition, the NC diets were supplemented further with the third limiting AA, Thr (40+3AA; NC + Lys, Trp, and Thr), and fourth and fifth limiting AA, His and Ile (40+5AA; NC + Lys, Trp, Thr, His, and Ile), based on the assumption that the apparent ileal digestibility of all indispensable AA in FM is 40%. Pigs had ad libitum access to feed and water. At the end of the study (112.1+/-1.8 kg), blood samples were collected from all pigs before slaughter. As expected, overall ADFI, AID Lys (representing indispensable AA) intake (LysI), ADG, and G:F were greater and BW gain:LysI (G:LysI) was less in pigs fed the PC diet than those fed the NC diet (P<0.001). Pigs fed the NRC diet grew slower than those fed the PC diet (P=0.004), and their G:LysI tended to be less than those fed the PC (P=0.083) or the 40+3AA and 40+5AA diets (P=0.094). Greater fat-free lean percentage (P=0.005), fat-free lean gain (LG; P<0.001), and LG:F (P<0.001) were observed in pigs fed the PC diet compared with those fed the NC diet, but their LG:F or LG:LysI was similar to those fed the NRC diet. However, LG:F (P=0.030) and LG:LysI (P=0.028) were greater in pigs fed the 40+3AA and the 40+5AA diets than those fed the NRC diet. Pigs fed the 40+5AA diet tended to utilize AID Lys more efficiently for LG than those fed the 40+3AA diet (P=0.068). Subjective meat color (P<0.001), firmness (P=0.004), and marbling (P<0.001) scores were greater in pigs fed the 40+5AA diet than those fed the 40+3AA diet. Diets seemed to have no clear effect on the weight of liver, kidney, and heart or serum urea N and triacylglycerides. Pigs fed the PC diet had more serum albumin and total protein (P<0.001), but less glucose (P=0.031) and cholesterol (P<0.001) than those fed the NC diet. Serum total protein was greater (P=0.031) in pigs fed the 40+5AA diet than those fed the 40+3AA diet. The results indicated that the corn-FM diets were not as effective as the corn-SBM diet in supporting BW gain of finisher pigs. However, the results seemed to indicate that pigs fed the corn-FM diet supplemented with the necessary AA can utilize feed and AA for BW gain and lean gain as efficiently as those fed the corn-SBM diet. Further research is needed to explore fully the optimal AA supplementation strategy to effectively utilize FM for pig production.
本研究的目的是确定在育肥猪日粮中用水解羽毛粉(FM)完全替代豆粕(SBM)的可能性。将45头后备母猪和45头去势公猪(体重57.8±0.8千克;每栏3头后备母猪或3头去势公猪)随机分配到5种育肥-1日粮中,每种日粮6栏。当栏内平均体重达到81.0±1.4千克时,给猪提供育肥-2日粮。玉米-豆粕型、育肥-1和育肥-2阳性对照(PC)日粮分别配制为每千克含有6.1克和4.7克表观回肠可消化(AID)赖氨酸。玉米-羽毛粉型阴性对照(NC)日粮配制为与PC日粮等氮。根据1998年NRC报告的羽毛粉中AID氨基酸情况,NC日粮添加赖氨酸和色氨酸(NRC;NC+赖氨酸和色氨酸)以缓解明显的不足。此外,基于羽毛粉中所有必需氨基酸的表观回肠消化率为40%的假设,NC日粮进一步添加第三限制性氨基酸苏氨酸(40+3AA;NC+赖氨酸、色氨酸和苏氨酸)以及第四和第五限制性氨基酸组氨酸和异亮氨酸(40+5AA;NC+赖氨酸、色氨酸、苏氨酸、组氨酸和异亮氨酸)。猪可自由采食饲料和饮水。在研究结束时(体重112.1±1.8千克),屠宰前从所有猪采集血样。正如预期的那样,与饲喂NC日粮的猪相比,饲喂PC日粮的猪的总体日均采食量、AID赖氨酸(代表必需氨基酸)摄入量(赖氨酸摄入量)、日均增重和料重比更高,而体重增加:赖氨酸摄入量(增重:赖氨酸摄入量)更低(P<0.001)。饲喂NRC日粮的猪比饲喂PC日粮的猪生长慢(P=0.004),其增重:赖氨酸摄入量倾向于低于饲喂PC日粮(P=0.083)或40+3AA和40+5AA日粮(P=0.094)的猪。与饲喂NC日粮的猪相比,饲喂PC日粮的猪的无脂瘦肉率更高(P=0.005)、无脂瘦肉增重(LG;P<0.001)和LG:料重比更高(P<0.001),但其LG:料重比或LG:赖氨酸摄入量与饲喂NRC日粮的猪相似。然而,饲喂40+3AA和40+5AA日粮的猪的LG:料重比(P=0.030)和LG:赖氨酸摄入量(P=0.028)高于饲喂NRC日粮的猪。与饲喂40+3AA日粮的猪相比,饲喂40+5AA日粮的猪似乎更有效地利用AID赖氨酸进行LG(P=0.068)。饲喂40+5AA日粮的猪的主观肉色评分(P<0.001)、硬度评分(P=0.004)和大理石花纹评分(P<0.001)高于饲喂40+3AA日粮的猪。日粮似乎对肝脏、肾脏和心脏重量或血清尿素氮和甘油三酯没有明显影响。与饲喂NC日粮的猪相比,饲喂PC日粮的猪血清白蛋白和总蛋白含量更高(P<0.001),但葡萄糖含量更低(P=0.031)和胆固醇含量更低(P<0.001)。饲喂40+5AA日粮的猪血清总蛋白含量高于饲喂40+3AA日粮的猪(P=0.031)。结果表明,玉米-羽毛粉日粮在支持育肥猪体重增加方面不如玉米-豆粕日粮有效。然而,结果似乎表明,饲喂添加了必需氨基酸的玉米-羽毛粉日粮的猪在利用饲料和氨基酸进行体重增加和瘦肉增重方面与饲喂玉米-豆粕日粮的猪一样高效。需要进一步研究以充分探索最佳氨基酸补充策略,从而有效利用羽毛粉用于生猪生产。