MacDonald D B, Al-Zayed Z, Stigsby B, Al-Homoud I
Section of Neurophysiology, Department of Neurosciences, King Faisal Specialist Hospital & Research Center, MBC 76, P.O. Box 3354, Riyadh 11211, Saudi Arabia.
Clin Neurophysiol. 2009 Feb;120(2):315-28. doi: 10.1016/j.clinph.2008.10.154. Epub 2008 Dec 25.
To form median somatosensory evoked potential (SEP) monitoring recommendations based on signal-to-noise ratio (SNR).
Two 1024-sweep right median SEP trials were recorded in 35 patients undergoing spine surgery. The SNR (signal power/noise power) and sweeps to reproducibility (<30% and <20% signal variation) were compared between the following derivations: cubital fossa (CF), Erb's point (EPi-EPc, EPi-M, EPi-Fz), cervical (C5S-EPc, C5S-AC, C5S-M, C5S-Fz), subcortical (CPi-EPc, CPi-M), and cortical (CPc-EPc, CPc-M, CPc-FPz, CPc-Fz, CPc-CPi, CPc-CPz), where M was the mastoid.
Higher SNR produced markedly faster reproducibility. The CF derivation had very high SNR and single-sweep reproducibility. Of cortical derivations, CPc-CPz had highest mean SNR and fastest overall reproducibility (median 50 and 120 sweeps to <30% and <20% signal variation); occasionally CPc-Fz or CPc-CPi was better. Of Erb's point and cervical derivations, EPi-M and C5S-M had highest mean SNR and fastest reproducibility. Subcortical derivations had very low mean SNR and slow or non-reproducibility. High voltage EEG degraded cortical and subcortical derivation SNR and reproducibility in young children.
The highest SNR derivations should be used to speed surgical feedback; slower low-SNR derivations should be omitted. Consequently, the CF is the best technical control and CPc-CPz should be the standard cortical derivation, with CPc-Fz and CPc-CPi as alternates. EPi-M and C5S-M are the best Erb's point and cervical derivations, but are optional. Subcortical derivations should be omitted. A presence/absence criterion or SEP omission may be indicated for some young children.
The results should influence future guidelines.
基于信噪比(SNR)制定正中神经体感诱发电位(SEP)监测建议。
对35例接受脊柱手术的患者进行了两次1024次扫描的右侧正中神经SEP试验。比较了以下导联的SNR(信号功率/噪声功率)和达到可重复性的扫描次数(信号变化<30%和<20%):肘窝(CF)、Erb点(EPi-EPc、EPi-M、EPi-Fz)、颈部(C5S-EPc、C5S-AC、C5S-M、C5S-Fz)、皮层下(CPi-EPc、CPi-M)和皮层(CPc-EPc、CPc-M、CPc-FPz、CPc-Fz、CPc-CPi、CPc-CPz),其中M为乳突。
较高的SNR可显著加快可重复性。CF导联具有非常高的SNR和单次扫描可重复性。在皮层导联中,CPc-CPz的平均SNR最高,总体可重复性最快(达到信号变化<30%和<20%的中位数分别为50次和120次扫描);偶尔CPc-Fz或CPc-CPi更好。在Erb点和颈部导联中,EPi-M和C5S-M的平均SNR最高,可重复性最快。皮层下导联的平均SNR非常低,可重复性慢或无重复性。高电压脑电图会降低幼儿皮层和皮层下导联的SNR及可重复性。
应使用SNR最高的导联来加快手术反馈;应省略SNR较低且较慢的导联。因此,CF是最佳的技术对照,CPc-CPz应作为标准的皮层导联,CPc-Fz和CPc-CPi作为备选。EPi-M和C5S-M是最佳的Erb点和颈部导联,但为可选。应省略皮层下导联。对于一些幼儿,可能需要制定存在/缺失标准或SEP缺失标准。
研究结果应会影响未来的指南。