Chen Nan-Yu, Huang Po-Yen, Leu Hsieh-Shong, Chiang Ping-Cheng, Huang Ching-Tai
Division of Infectious Diseases, Department of Internal Medicine, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Chang Gung University College of Medicine, Taoyuan, Taiwan.
J Microbiol Immunol Infect. 2008 Oct;41(5):362-8.
Several rickettsioses are endemic in Taiwan. They are under-reported not only because of ignorance but also due to difficulty in recognition caused by their nonspecific manifestations, which overlap with other acute febrile illnesses. We conducted a retrospective study to delineate distinctive clinical features of rickettsiosis, in order to develop a system for differential diagnosis of rickettsiosis.
Patients admitted to Chang Gung Memorial Hospital Linkou Medical Center, Taoyuan, Taiwan, with suspected rickettsiosis during the period from January 2004 to May 2006 were included. Clinical suspicion was based on the presence of acute fever with eschar formation, relevant contact history, poor response to broad-spectrum empiric antibacterial therapy, unexplained thrombocytopenia, leukopenia, or abnormal liver biochemistry, or unexplained major organ involvement. Serum samples were sent to the Centers for Disease Control, Taiwan, for serologic diagnosis of the 3 rickettsioses endemic to Taiwan - scrub typhus (Tsutsugamushi's disease), murine typhus (endemic typhus) and Q fever. Serologically confirmed and excluded cases were compared for signs and symptoms, risk factors, laboratory findings and response to treatment.
Among 138 suspected cases, 88 were excluded from the study because of incomplete serological tests or insufficient information, 28 were confirmed to have one of the 3 rickettsioses and 22 were negative for all of them. Distinct features among confirmed cases, compared to controls, were eschar formation, relevant contact history, and presence of atypical lymphocytes in peripheral blood. Normal or low leukocyte count, thrombocytopenia and relative bradycardia were not significant in predicting diagnosis. We propose a predictive system for tentative diagnosis of rickettsiosis based on relevant clinical attributes. This system has a positive predictive value of 80% and a negative predictive value of 100%.
The predictive scoring system may allow institution of appropriate treatment for rickettsiosis in a more timely manner. However, a low probability of diagnosis should prompt vigorous search for other etiologies.
台湾地区存在多种立克次体病地方性流行。这些疾病报告不足,不仅是因为认识不足,还由于其非特异性表现与其他急性发热性疾病重叠,导致难以识别。我们进行了一项回顾性研究,以描绘立克次体病的独特临床特征,从而建立一个立克次体病鉴别诊断系统。
纳入2004年1月至2006年5月期间入住台湾桃园长庚纪念医院林口医学中心、疑似患立克次体病的患者。临床怀疑基于急性发热伴焦痂形成、相关接触史、对广谱经验性抗菌治疗反应不佳、不明原因的血小板减少、白细胞减少或肝功能异常,或不明原因的主要器官受累。血清样本被送往台湾疾病控制中心,用于对台湾地区流行的三种立克次体病——恙虫病、鼠型斑疹伤寒(地方性斑疹伤寒)和Q热进行血清学诊断。对血清学确诊和排除的病例进行症状体征、危险因素、实验室检查结果及治疗反应的比较。
138例疑似病例中,88例因血清学检查不完整或信息不足被排除在研究之外,28例确诊患三种立克次体病之一,22例三种立克次体病血清学检查均为阴性。与对照组相比,确诊病例的独特特征为焦痂形成、相关接触史及外周血中出现异型淋巴细胞。白细胞计数正常或降低、血小板减少及相对心动过缓对诊断的预测价值不大。我们提出了一个基于相关临床特征对立克次体病进行初步诊断的预测系统。该系统的阳性预测值为80%,阴性预测值为100%。
该预测评分系统可能有助于更及时地对立克次体病进行适当治疗。然而,诊断概率较低时应积极寻找其他病因。