Livesey Geoffrey, Tagami Hiroyuki
Independent Nutrition Logic, Pealerswell House, Wymondham, Norfolk, UK.
Am J Clin Nutr. 2009 Jan;89(1):114-25. doi: 10.3945/ajcn.2008.26842.
The glycemic response to diet has been linked with noncommunicable diseases and is reduced by low-palatable, viscous, soluble fiber (1). Whether a palatable, low-viscous, soluble fiber such as resistant maltodextrin (RMD) has the same effect is unclear.
The objective was to assess evidence on the attenuation of the blood glucose response to foods by < or = 10 g RMD in healthy adults.
We conducted a systematic review of randomized, placebo-controlled trials with the use of fixed- and random-effects meta-analyses and meta-regression models.
We found data from 37 relevant trials to April 2007. These trials investigated the attenuation of the glycemic response to rice, noodles, pastry, bread, and refined carbohydrates that included 30-173 g available carbohydrate. RMD was administered in drinks or liquid foods or solid foods. Placebo drinks and foods excluded RMD. Percentage attenuation was significant, dose-dependent, and independent of the amount of available carbohydrate coingested. Attenuation of the glycemic response to starchy foods by 6 g RMD in drinks approached approximately 20%, but when placed directly into foods was approximately 10% -- significant (P < 0.001) by both modes of administration. Study quality analyses, funnel plots, and trim-and-fill analyses uncovered no cause of significant systematic bias. Studies from authors affiliated with organizations for-profit were symmetrical without heterogeneity, whereas marginal asymmetry and significant heterogeneity arose among studies involving authors from nonprofit organizations because of some imprecise studies.
A nonviscous palatable soluble polysaccharide can attenuate the glycemic response to carbohydrate foods. Evidence of an effect was stronger for RMD in drinks than in foods.
饮食的血糖反应与非传染性疾病有关,而低口感、粘性、可溶性纤维可降低该反应(1)。尚不清楚诸如抗性麦芽糊精(RMD)这种口感好、低粘性的可溶性纤维是否具有相同效果。
目的是评估健康成年人中10克及以下RMD对食物血糖反应的减弱作用的证据。
我们使用固定效应和随机效应荟萃分析以及荟萃回归模型对随机、安慰剂对照试验进行了系统评价。
我们找到了截至2007年4月的37项相关试验的数据。这些试验研究了RMD对大米、面条、糕点、面包和精制碳水化合物的血糖反应减弱作用,其中包括30 - 173克可利用碳水化合物。RMD通过饮料、流质食物或固体食物给药。安慰剂饮料和食物不含RMD。血糖反应减弱的百分比具有显著性、剂量依赖性,且与同时摄入的可利用碳水化合物量无关。饮料中6克RMD使淀粉类食物的血糖反应减弱约20%,但直接添加到食物中时约为10%——两种给药方式均具有显著性(P < 0.001)。研究质量分析、漏斗图分析和修剪填充分析未发现显著系统偏差的原因。来自营利性组织作者的研究呈对称分布且无异质性,而涉及非营利组织作者的研究中出现了边际不对称和显著异质性,原因是部分研究不够精确。
一种低粘性、口感好的可溶性多糖可减弱碳水化合物食物的血糖反应。RMD在饮料中的作用证据比在食物中更强。