Hughes John R
Department of Neurology, University of Illinois Medical Center at Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA.
Epilepsy Behav. 2009 Feb;14(2):280-7. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2008.12.004. Epub 2009 Jan 6.
This review attempts to provide up-to-date quantitative data from published reports on sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP) appearing on Medline and, especially, to provide a means to predict the probability of SUDEP in a given patient. The mean incidence of SUDEP was 1.8/1000, similar to the median of 1.5. The mean standardized mortality ratio was 6.8, and the mean percentage of SUDEP cases among deaths from epilepsy was 16.6. Seventeen risk factors were identified, each given a value according to the number of studies in the literature that specified that condition as a significant risk. The addition of these 17 values then indicated the risk for a given patient. The author calculated these for a group of 91 patients who died of SUDEP and also for 91 live patients. Many of their values for the different risks were significantly different. The sensitivity of these SUDEP values was 71.3%, the specificity 81.8%, and the positive predictive value 84.6%. A discussion includes the question of whether the death in SUDEP is primarily cardiac or pulmonary and the suggestion that it may be either or both in a given patient. The most important risk factor in this study was noncompliance with antiepileptic medication, and the main message of this study to caregivers is that therapeutic drug levels are crucial to avoid SUDEP.
本综述旨在提供来自发表在Medline上关于癫痫性猝死(SUDEP)报告中的最新定量数据,尤其是提供一种预测特定患者发生SUDEP概率的方法。SUDEP的平均发病率为1.8/1000,与中位数1.5相似。平均标准化死亡率为6.8,癫痫死亡病例中SUDEP病例的平均百分比为16.6。确定了17个风险因素,每个因素根据文献中指明该因素为显著风险的研究数量赋予一个值。将这17个值相加,然后表明特定患者的风险。作者为一组91例死于SUDEP的患者以及91例存活患者计算了这些值。他们在不同风险方面的许多值存在显著差异。这些SUDEP值的敏感性为71.3%,特异性为81.8%,阳性预测值为84.6%。讨论内容包括SUDEP中的死亡主要是心脏性还是肺部性的问题,以及在特定患者中可能是其中之一或两者皆有的观点。本研究中最重要的风险因素是不遵守抗癫痫药物治疗,并且本研究给护理人员的主要信息是治疗药物水平对于避免SUDEP至关重要。