Sawyer Adam R, See Marlene, Nduka Charles
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Department, Queen Victoria Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, West Sussex, England.
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2009 Jan;140(1):76-81. doi: 10.1016/j.otohns.2008.09.007.
There is little research into analyzing whether facial expression changes are secondary to actual treatment or normal day-to-day variation. This study aims to ascertain whether nine-facial expressions were reproducible.
Thirty-nine white subjects performed nine-facial expressions, captured by three-dimensional stereophotogrammetry in three sessions. After initial capture (session 1), each expression was repeated after 15 minutes (session 2) and then 4 weeks (session 3) after the initial session. Statistical analysis was performed on the mean variability of facial landmarks between session 1 and 2 and session 1 and 3.
Repose was the most reproducible expression. The least reproducible was "blow-out-the-cheeks." Analysis between session 1 and 2 showed no significant differences in expression reproducibility. Analysis between session 1 and 3 showed significant differences for the "smile-with-lips-open" and "blow-out-the-cheeks" expressions.
Facial expressions are reproducible in a 15-minute period. There are significant differences in the ability to reproduce facial expressions 4 weeks apart for "smile-with-lips-open" and "blow-out-the-cheeks."
关于分析面部表情变化是实际治疗的继发结果还是正常日常变化的研究很少。本研究旨在确定九种面部表情是否可重现。
39名白人受试者进行了九种面部表情的展示,通过三维立体摄影测量法在三个阶段进行捕捉。在初次捕捉(阶段1)后,每种表情在15分钟后(阶段2)重复展示,然后在初次展示4周后(阶段3)再次重复展示。对阶段1与阶段2以及阶段1与阶段3之间面部标志点的平均变异性进行了统计分析。
平静表情是最可重现的表情。最不可重现的是“鼓起脸颊”。阶段1与阶段2之间的分析显示表情可重现性无显著差异。阶段1与阶段3之间的分析显示“张嘴微笑”和“鼓起脸颊”表情存在显著差异。
面部表情在15分钟内是可重现的。对于“张嘴微笑”和“鼓起脸颊”表情,相隔4周重现面部表情的能力存在显著差异。