Chen Chan-Cheng, Wang Tzu-Chi, Liaw Horng-Jang, Chen Hui-Chu
Department of Occupational Safety and Health, China Medical University, 91 Hsueh-Shih Road, Taichung 404, Taiwan.
J Hazard Mater. 2009 Jul 30;166(2-3):880-90. doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2008.11.093. Epub 2008 Dec 3.
Theoretical models to predict the upper/lower flammability limits of hydrocarbons diluted with inert nitrogen gas are proposed in this study. It is found that there are linear relations between the reciprocal of the upper/lower flammability limits and the reciprocal of the molar fraction of hydrocarbon in the hydrocarbon/inert nitrogen mixture. Such linearity is examined by experimental data reported in the literature, which include the cases of methane, propane, ethylene and propylene. The R-squared values (R(2)) of the regression lines of the cases explored are all greater than 0.989 for upper flammability limit (UFL). The theoretical slope of the predictive line for lower flammability limit (LFL) is found to be very close to zero for all explored cases; and this result successfully explains the experimental fact that adding inert nitrogen to a flammable material has very limited effect on LFL. Because limit oxygen concentration (LOC) could be taken as the intersectional point of the UFL curve and LFL curve, a LOC-based method is proposed to predict the slope of the UFL curve when experimental data of UFL are not available. This LOC-based method predicts the UFL with average error ranging from 2.17% to 5.84% and maximum error ranging from 8.58% to 12.18% for the cases explored. The predictive models for inert gas of nitrogen are also extended to the case of inert gas other than nitrogen. Through the extended models, it was found that the inert ability of an inert gas depends on its mean molar heat capacity at the adiabatic flame temperature. Theoretical calculation shows that the inert abilities of carbon dioxide, steam, nitrogen and helium are in the following order: carbon dioxide>steam>nitrogen>helium; and this sequence conforms to the existing experimental data reported in the literature.
本研究提出了预测用惰性氮气稀释的碳氢化合物的上/下燃烧极限的理论模型。研究发现,在碳氢化合物/惰性氮气混合物中,上/下燃烧极限的倒数与碳氢化合物摩尔分数的倒数之间存在线性关系。文献报道的实验数据对这种线性关系进行了检验,这些数据包括甲烷、丙烷、乙烯和丙烯的情况。对于上燃烧极限(UFL),所研究案例的回归线的决定系数(R²)均大于0.989。对于所有研究案例,发现下燃烧极限(LFL)预测线的理论斜率非常接近零;这一结果成功地解释了向可燃材料中添加惰性氮气对LFL影响非常有限这一实验事实。由于极限氧浓度(LOC)可被视为UFL曲线和LFL曲线的交点,因此提出了一种基于LOC的方法,用于在没有UFL实验数据时预测UFL曲线的斜率。对于所研究的案例,这种基于LOC的方法预测UFL的平均误差范围为2.17%至5.84%,最大误差范围为8.58%至12.18%。氮气惰性气体的预测模型也扩展到了除氮气以外的惰性气体情况。通过扩展模型发现,惰性气体的惰性能力取决于其在绝热火焰温度下的平均摩尔热容。理论计算表明,二氧化碳、蒸汽、氮气和氦气的惰性能力顺序如下:二氧化碳>蒸汽>氮气>氦气;这一顺序与文献报道的现有实验数据一致。