Huh Jin, Shin Hwa-Yong, Kim Seong-Hyop, Yoon Tae-Kyoon, Kim Duk-Kyung
Department of Anesthesiology, Seoul National University Borame Municipal Hospital, Korea.
Anesth Analg. 2009 Feb;108(2):544-8. doi: 10.1213/ane.0b013e31818fc347.
We evaluated the usefulness of the hyomental distance (HMD) ratio (HMDR), defined as the ratio of the HMD at the extreme of head extension to that in the neutral position, in predicting difficult visualization of the larynx (DVL) in apparently normal patients, by examining the following preoperative airway predictors, alone and in combination: the modified Mallampati test, HMD in the neutral position, HMD and thyromental distance at the extreme of head extension and HMDR.
Preoperatively, we assessed the five airway predictors in 213 adult patients undergoing general anesthesia with tracheal intubation. A single experienced anesthesiologist, blinded to the results of the airway evaluation, performed all of the direct laryngoscopies and graded the views using the modified Cormack and Lehane scale. DVL was defined as a Grade 3 or 4 view. The optimal cutoff points for each test were determined at the maximal point of the area under the curve in the receiver operating characteristic curve. For the modified Mallampati test, Class >or=3 was predefined as a predictor of DVL.
The larynx was difficult to visualize in 26 (12.2%) patients. In univariate analyses, the HMD and thyromental distance at the extreme of head extension and the HMDR were significantly related to DVL. The HMDR with the optimal cutoff point of 1.2 had greater diagnostic accuracy (area under the curve of 0.782), than other single predictors (P < 0.05), and it alone showed a greater diagnostic validity profile (sensitivity, 88%; specificity, 60%) than any test combinations.
The HMDR with a test threshold of 1.2 is a clinically reliable predictor of DVL.
我们通过单独及联合检查以下术前气道预测指标,评估了颏下距(HMD)比率(HMDR)(定义为头部极度后仰时的HMD与中立位时的HMD之比)在预测表面正常患者的喉镜视野困难(DVL)方面的效用:改良Mallampati试验、中立位时的HMD、头部极度后仰时的HMD和甲状颏距以及HMDR。
术前,我们对213例接受气管插管全身麻醉的成年患者评估了这五项气道预测指标。由一名对气道评估结果不知情的经验丰富的麻醉医生进行所有直接喉镜检查,并使用改良的Cormack和Lehane分级标准对视野进行分级。DVL定义为3级或4级视野。在受试者工作特征曲线中曲线下面积的最大值处确定每项检查的最佳截断点。对于改良Mallampati试验,≥3级预先定义为DVL的预测指标。
26例(12.2%)患者的喉镜视野困难。在单因素分析中,头部极度后仰时的HMD和甲状颏距以及HMDR与DVL显著相关。最佳截断点为1.2的HMDR比其他单一预测指标具有更高的诊断准确性(曲线下面积为0.782)(P<0.05),并且其单独显示出比任何检查组合更高的诊断有效性(敏感性为88%;特异性为60%)。
试验阈值为1.2的HMDR是DVL的临床可靠预测指标。