Lu Lin, Liu Yanli, Zhu Weili, Shi Jie, Liu Yu, Ling Walter, Kosten Thomas R
National Institute on Drug Dependence, Peking University, Beijing, China.
Am J Drug Alcohol Abuse. 2009;35(1):1-11. doi: 10.1080/00952990802455469.
To evaluate clinical trials and neurochemical mechanisms of the action of traditional herbal remedies and acupuncture for treating drug addiction.
We used computerized literature searches in English and Chinese and examined texts written before these computerized databases existed. We used search terms of treatment and neurobiology of herbal medicines, and acupuncture for drug abuse and dependence.
Acupuncture showed evidence for clinical efficacy and relevant neurobiological mechanisms in opiate withdrawal, but it showed poor efficacy for alcohol and nicotine withdrawal or relapse prevention, and no large studies supported its efficacy for cocaine in well-designed clinical trials. Clinical trials were rare for herbal remedies. Radix Puerariae showed the most promising efficacy for alcoholism by acting through daidzin, which inhibits mitocochondrial aldehyde dehydrogenase 2 and leads to disulfiram-like alcohol reactions. Peyote also has some evidence for alcoholism treatment among Native Americans. Ginseng and Kava lack efficacy data in addictions, and Kava can be hepatotoxic. Thunbergia laurifolia can protect against alcoholic liver toxicity. Withania somnifera and Salvia miltiorrhiza have no efficacy data, but can reduce morphine tolerance and alcohol intake, respectively, in animal models.
Traditional herbal treatments can compliment pharmacotherapies for drug withdrawal and possibly relapse prevention with less expense and perhaps fewer side effects with notable exceptions. Both acupuncture and herbal treatments need testing as adjuncts to reduce doses and durations of standard pharmacotherapies.
评估传统草药疗法及针灸治疗药物成瘾的临床试验及神经化学作用机制。
我们利用英文和中文的计算机文献检索,并查阅了在这些计算机数据库出现之前撰写的文本。我们使用了草药的治疗与神经生物学以及针灸治疗药物滥用和依赖的检索词。
针灸在阿片类药物戒断方面显示出临床疗效及相关神经生物学机制的证据,但在酒精和尼古丁戒断或预防复发方面疗效不佳,且在精心设计的临床试验中,没有大型研究支持其对可卡因的疗效。草药疗法的临床试验很少。葛根通过大豆苷元发挥作用,对酒精中毒显示出最有前景的疗效,大豆苷元可抑制线粒体乙醛脱氢酶2并导致类似双硫仑的酒精反应。仙人球毒碱在美洲原住民中治疗酒精中毒也有一些证据。人参和卡瓦在成瘾方面缺乏疗效数据,且卡瓦可能具有肝毒性。白花蛇舌草可预防酒精性肝毒性。印度人参和丹参没有疗效数据,但在动物模型中分别可降低吗啡耐受性和酒精摄入量。
传统草药治疗可以补充药物疗法用于药物戒断,并可能预防复发,费用较低且副作用可能较少,但有明显例外。针灸和草药治疗都需要作为辅助手段进行测试,以减少标准药物疗法的剂量和疗程。