Colletti Liliana
ENT Department, University of Verona, Verona, Italy.
Acta Otolaryngol. 2009 Apr;129(4):361-6. doi: 10.1080/00016480802495453.
In this study the outcomes from several indices (Category of Auditory Performance, CAP; Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test (Revised), PPVT-R; Test of Reception of Grammar, TROG; and Speech Intellegibility Rating, SIR) in three groups of children with different ages at implantation (from 4 to 36 months) with a follow-up time from 4 to 9 years demonstrate that very early cochlear implantation (<11 months) provides normalization of audio-phonologic parameters with no complications.
The aim of the present study was to investigate the efficacy of cochlear implants (CIs) in infants who were implanted at < 11 months of age versus children operated at later age (i.e. 12-36 months) and to document whether children who receive a CI below 11 months of age are able to achieve age-appropriate expected spoken language skills, at a follow-up time from 4 to 9 years.
From November 1998 to November 2007, 185 children received CIs and 34 received auditory brainstem implants in our department. The present study focuses on 13 children implanted at ages younger than 12 months (4-11 months; mean, 8.2; SD = 2.4) and fitted with CIs between November 1998 and March 2004. To avoid bias these children were selected from a larger longitudinal cohort of pediatric CI recipients fitted with CIs because they all were implanted with the same cochlear device (Nucleus CI 24 M) during the same period. Postoperatively auditory abilities were evaluated at the latest follow-up, from 4 to 9 years after surgery, with CAP, PPVT-R, TROG, and SIR. The results obtained in this group of 13 children were compared with those obtained in two groups of children implanted at later ages (12-23 and 24-36 months, respectively).
No complication has been observed so far. The highest score of CAP function was achieved in all the three groups but at different intervals from CI activation as function of age at CI implantation. The rate of receptive language growth (PPVT-R) provides distinctive evidence that only the scores of the first group overlap the line of normal-hearing children, whereas the second and third group never reached the values of normal peers even after 9 years of CI use. TROG outcomes clearly indicate that only children from the first group (77%) are in the 76-100 percentile at 5 years follow-up. At 9 years follow-up, 100% of children in the first group, 38% in the second group, and 20% in the third group are in the 76-100 percentile. The SIR outcomes at the 5 years follow-up indicate that none of children was identified within the first two categories, only children from the third group (18%) were identified in category 3, all infants of the first group, 80% of group 2, and 63% of the third group were identified in category 5. At the 9 years follow-up, the number of children from the third group identified in category 3 was reduced to 10%, the second and third groups displayed a slightly higher percentage of children in category 5, but the difference from the values observed at the 5-year follow-up is not significant.
在本研究中,对三组不同植入年龄(4至36个月)且随访时间为4至9年的儿童的多个指标(听觉表现类别,CAP;皮博迪图片词汇测试(修订版),PPVT - R;语法接受测试,TROG;以及言语可懂度评分,SIR)的结果进行分析,结果表明极早期人工耳蜗植入(<11个月)可使听 - 语音参数正常化且无并发症。
本研究的目的是调查11个月龄前接受人工耳蜗植入的婴儿与稍大年龄(即12 - 36个月)接受手术的儿童相比人工耳蜗植入的效果,并记录11个月龄前接受人工耳蜗植入的儿童在4至9年的随访期内是否能够达到与其年龄相适应的预期口语技能。
从1998年11月至2007年11月,在我们科室有185名儿童接受了人工耳蜗植入,34名接受了听觉脑干植入。本研究聚焦于13名12个月龄前(4 - 11个月;平均8.2个月;标准差 = 2.4)接受人工耳蜗植入且于1998年11月至2004年3月期间安装人工耳蜗的儿童。为避免偏差,这些儿童是从更大的一组纵向儿科人工耳蜗植入受者队列中挑选出来的,因为他们在同一时期均植入了相同的人工耳蜗装置(Nucleus CI 24 M)。术后在最新的随访中,即手术后4至9年,使用CAP、PPVT - R、TROG和SIR对听觉能力进行评估。将这13名儿童组的结果与两组稍大年龄(分别为12 - 23个月和24 - 36个月)植入人工耳蜗的儿童的结果进行比较。
到目前为止未观察到并发症。所有三组均达到了CAP功能的最高分,但根据人工耳蜗植入时的年龄不同,达到最高分的时间间隔也不同。接受性语言增长速率(PPVT - R)提供了独特的证据,表明只有第一组儿童的分数与正常听力儿童的分数线重叠,而第二组和第三组即使在使用人工耳蜗9年后也从未达到正常同龄人的分数值。TROG结果清楚地表明,只有第一组儿童(77%)在5年随访时处于第76 - 100百分位。在9年随访时,第一组儿童的100%、第二组儿童的38%以及第三组儿童的20%处于第76 - 100百分位。5年随访时的SIR结果表明,在前两个类别中未发现儿童,只有第三组儿童(18%)被归为第3类;第一组所有婴儿、第二组80%的儿童以及第三组63%的儿童被归为第5类。在9年随访时,第三组中被归为第3类的儿童数量降至10%,第二组和第三组在第5类中的儿童百分比略高,但与5年随访时观察到的值相比差异不显著。