McVay Marcene R, Copeland Daniel R, McMahon Lisa E, Cosper Graham H, McCallie Theresa G, Kokoska Evan R, Jackson Richard J, Smith Samuel D
Arkansas Children's Hospital, Little Rock, 72202-3591, USA.
J Pediatr Surg. 2009 Jan;44(1):169-71; discussion 171-2. doi: 10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2008.10.028.
We will demonstrate that a surgical resident with proven accuracy in the diagnosis of hypertrophic pyloric stenosis (HPS) can teach other surgeons to diagnose HPS with reproducible accuracy.
A surgical resident with proven sonographic accuracy in diagnosing HPS instructed 5 other surgical residents in the technique. Consecutive patients referred to pediatric surgery with a presumed clinical diagnosis of HPS were examined, and measurements of residents were compared with formal radiology studies. Each surgeon was proctored for 5 examinations before independent evaluation and was blinded to results from both radiologists and other residents. Results were evaluated using Student's t test; P less than .05 was considered significant.
Seventy-one patients were evaluated by 5 surgical residents. Residents were diagnostically accurate in all cases. There was no statistically significant difference between pyloric muscle thickness or channel length measurements obtained by radiology and any of the residents.
Surgeon-performed ultrasound examination for the diagnosis of HPS is accurate and reproducible through surgeon-to-surgeon instruction on appropriate technique. This skill is a valuable asset in the initial surgical evaluation of any patient with suspected HPS, expediting appropriate management.
我们将证明,在肥厚性幽门狭窄(HPS)诊断方面已被证实具有准确性的外科住院医师能够教会其他外科医生以可重复的准确性诊断HPS。
一名在诊断HPS方面已被证实具有超声检查准确性的外科住院医师向其他5名外科住院医师传授该技术。对连续转诊至小儿外科且临床诊断疑似HPS的患者进行检查,并将住院医师的测量结果与正式的放射学研究结果进行比较。在独立评估前,每位外科医生在接受指导下进行5次检查,且对放射科医生和其他住院医师的结果均不知情。使用学生t检验评估结果;P值小于0.05被认为具有统计学意义。
5名外科住院医师对71例患者进行了评估。住院医师在所有病例中的诊断均准确。放射学检查测得的幽门肌厚度或通道长度与任何一名住院医师测得的结果之间无统计学显著差异。
通过外科医生之间关于适当技术的指导,外科医生进行的超声检查用于诊断HPS是准确且可重复的。这项技能在对任何疑似HPS患者的初步外科评估中是一项宝贵资产,可加快适当的治疗。