Eifel P J, Gershenson D M, Delclos L, Wharton J T, Peters L J
Division of Radiotherapy, University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston 77030.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1991 Sep;21(4):1013-8. doi: 10.1016/0360-3016(91)90743-n.
Between July 1983 and December 1988, 34 patients with ovarian carcinoma received whole abdominal irradiation in an attempt to eliminate residual disease following second-look laparotomy. Three additional patients who had initial complete responses to chemotherapy were treated for a recurrence of their disease. All patients had been treated with chemotherapy that included cisplatin and cyclophosphamide. Three patients had also received doxorubicin with some or all chemotherapy cycles. Thirty Gray of abdominopelvic radiation therapy (APRT) was delivered using a twice-daily, split-course schedule. Eleven patients also had a boost of 9-20 Gy to sites of residual disease. Treatment was well tolerated. Only one patient did not complete therapy and two patients had 1-week prolongations of treatment because of hematologic toxicity. Thirty-two percent of patients had grade 2 neoplasms and 61% had grade 3 disease. Three patients with grade 1 tumors continue to have no evidence of disease 20-50 months after irradiation. Patients with grade 2 and 3 neoplasms who had microscopic residual disease prior to APRT had relapse-free survival rates at 3-years of 10% and 14%, respectively. Twelve patients with gross residual disease had rapid recurrences (median time to relapse, 4.9 months) and all have died of their disease. Although 14 patients (38%) have experienced small bowel obstructions, all of these had known recurrent abdominal disease at the time. Twenty patients (54%) had undergone more than two abdominal surgeries prior to APRT, and several were noted to have extensive adhesions at second-look laparotomy. None of the five patients currently believed to be free of disease has experienced a small bowel obstruction. Radiation is only one of several factors that contributed to bowel obstructions. Although APRT may be able to eliminate residual disease in a small proportion of patients with microscopic residual disease after chemotherapy, the aggressive biology of tumors that respond incompletely to chemotherapy and the compromises in radiation dose and schedule that must be made in these heavily treated patients probably contribute to the disappointing results of this treatment.
1983年7月至1988年12月期间,34例卵巢癌患者接受了全腹照射,试图在二次剖腹探查术后消除残留病灶。另外3例对化疗最初有完全反应的患者因疾病复发而接受治疗。所有患者均接受了包括顺铂和环磷酰胺在内的化疗。部分或全部化疗周期中,有3例患者还接受了阿霉素治疗。采用每日两次的分割疗程方案给予30戈瑞的腹盆腔放射治疗(APRT)。11例患者还对残留病灶部位追加了9 - 20戈瑞的照射。治疗耐受性良好。只有1例患者未完成治疗,2例患者因血液学毒性使治疗延长了1周。32%的患者为2级肿瘤,61%为3级疾病。3例1级肿瘤患者在照射后20 - 50个月仍无疾病证据。APRT前有微小残留病灶的2级和3级肿瘤患者,3年无复发生存率分别为10%和14%。12例有肉眼可见残留病灶的患者复发迅速(复发中位时间为4.9个月),均死于该疾病。虽然14例患者(38%)发生了小肠梗阻,但所有这些患者当时均已知有腹部疾病复发。20例患者(54%)在APRT前接受了两次以上的腹部手术,二次剖腹探查时发现其中几例有广泛粘连。目前认为无疾病的5例患者中,无一例发生小肠梗阻。放射只是导致肠梗阻的几个因素之一。虽然APRT可能能够在一小部分化疗后有微小残留病灶的患者中消除残留病灶,但对化疗反应不完全的肿瘤的侵袭性生物学特性以及在这些接受过大量治疗的患者中必须对放射剂量和疗程所做的妥协,可能是导致这种治疗结果令人失望的原因。