Wang Chi-Te, Lai Mei-Su, Young Yi-Ho
Department of Otolaryngology, Far Eastern Memorial Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan.
Headache. 2009 Mar;49(3):426-34. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4610.2008.01283.x. Epub 2008 Oct 10.
This study compared clinical manifestations and audiovestibular function tests among subjects of basilar-type migraine (BtM), definite and probable migrainous vertigo (dMV and pMV), in order to investigate the relationship between them.
Various diagnostic criteria such as BtM, dMV, and pMV have been proposed. However, a comparison between these diagnostic groups has not been conducted before.
This study enrolled 77 subjects, including BtM in 15, dMV in 30, and pMV in 32 patients. All patients received structured interview of clinical presentations and underwent a battery of audiovestibular function tests.
Demographic features were similar between 3 groups, including age, gender, precipitating factors, and family preponderance. When considering the clinical manifestations, for example motion sickness, migrainous symptoms, and sequential relationship between headache and vertigo, BtM and dMV groups shared similar features, but differed from pMV group. As regards to differentiate between BtM and dMV patients, the former revealed higher occurrence rates than the latter in relation to the frequency of vertigo attacks, neurological symptoms, and saccadic dysmetria.
The relationship between BtM, dMV, and pMV refers to a distribution of severity across the disease spectrum of migraine-related vertigo. Of them, BtM group presents the most severe form in clinical manifestation and brainstem involvement, followed by dMV, and pMV is the mildest form.
本研究比较了基底型偏头痛(BtM)、确诊和可能的偏头痛性眩晕(dMV和pMV)患者的临床表现及听前庭功能测试结果,以探讨它们之间的关系。
已提出多种诊断标准,如BtM、dMV和pMV。然而,此前尚未对这些诊断组进行过比较。
本研究纳入了77名受试者,其中15例为BtM,30例为dMV,32例为pMV。所有患者均接受了临床表现的结构化访谈,并进行了一系列听前庭功能测试。
三组患者的人口统计学特征相似,包括年龄、性别、诱发因素和家族倾向。在考虑临床表现时,例如晕动病、偏头痛症状以及头痛与眩晕的先后关系,BtM组和dMV组具有相似特征,但与pMV组不同。在区分BtM和dMV患者时,前者在眩晕发作频率、神经症状和眼球扫视运动障碍方面的发生率高于后者。
BtM、dMV和pMV之间的关系是偏头痛相关性眩晕疾病谱中严重程度的一种分布。其中,BtM组在临床表现和脑干受累方面表现出最严重的形式,其次是dMV,pMV是最轻微的形式。