Gacono C B, Meloy J R
Atascadero State Hospital, California.
J Nerv Ment Dis. 1991 Sep;179(9):546-52. doi: 10.1097/00005053-199109000-00005.
We investigated the constructs of anxiety and attachment in a group of 42 offenders who met the DSM-III-R criteria for antisocial personality disorder. Each antisocial subject's level of psychopathy was assessed with the Hare Psychopathy Checklist (PCL). Three Rorschach variables related to attachment, anxiety, and coping were compared between subjects scoring greater than or equal to 30 (N = 21) on the PCL and subjects scoring less than 30 (N = 21). Comparison Rorschach variables are also presented from a sample of 60 antisocial personality-disordered offenders. Moderate psychopaths (PCL score, less than 30) produced texture and diffuse shading responses at a significantly greater frequency than severe, or primary, psychopaths (PCL score, greater than or equal to 30). There was no significant difference in the two groups' propensity for producing vista responses. Although there were no significant differences between the coping index scores, the trend suggests less conflictual functioning in the severe psychopaths. A virtual absence of texture responses in the severe psychopaths, and a significantly greater frequency of diffuse shading responses in the moderate psychopaths, add construct validity to the lack of attachment in psychopaths and the role of anxiety in differentiating secondary from primary psychopathy. We view the presence of vista responses in this population as a measure of a failed grandiose self-structure, and note that it often occurs in the records of moderate psychopaths who also present achromatic color responses.
我们对42名符合DSM-III-R反社会人格障碍标准的罪犯进行了焦虑和依恋结构的调查。使用哈雷精神病态检查表(PCL)评估了每位反社会受试者的精神病态水平。比较了PCL得分大于或等于30分(N = 21)的受试者与得分低于30分(N = 21)的受试者在罗夏测验中与依恋、焦虑和应对相关的三个变量。还给出了来自60名反社会人格障碍罪犯样本的罗夏测验比较变量。中度精神病态者(PCL得分低于30分)产生质地和弥散阴影反应的频率明显高于重度或原发性精神病态者(PCL得分大于或等于30分)。两组产生远景反应的倾向没有显著差异。尽管应对指数得分没有显著差异,但趋势表明重度精神病态者的冲突功能较少。重度精神病态者几乎没有质地反应,而中度精神病态者弥散阴影反应的频率明显更高,这为精神病态者缺乏依恋以及焦虑在区分继发性与原发性精神病态中的作用增加了结构效度。我们将这一人群中远景反应的出现视为一种夸大的自我结构失败的指标,并注意到它经常出现在同时呈现消色差颜色反应的中度精神病态者的记录中。