Nguyen Kimanh D, Minor Lloyd B, Della Santina Charles C, Carey John P
Department of Otolaryngology-Head & Neck Surgery, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland 21287-0910, USA.
Laryngoscope. 2009 Apr;119(4):792-8. doi: 10.1002/lary.20055.
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: With low-dose and titration protocols, subsequent intratympanic (IT) gentamicin injections are frequently necessary for vertigo control in Ménière's disease. To date, studies have not provided detailed descriptions of the time course of recurrent vertigo and repeated injections. Our objective is to provide such a description with a Kaplan-Meier survival analysis, which may enable accurate predictions of the probability of recurrent vertigo after a given time or number of injections.
Injections of IT gentamicin were administered for unilateral definite Ménière's disease. One injection (or rarely more) in a 6-week period constituted a "round." Repeat rounds were given when needed for control of recurrent vertigo.
We used a Kaplan-Meier method to quantify percentages of patients with control of vertigo over an 8-year period. A separate curve was created for each number of rounds, and failure for each was defined as the need for an additional round.
Of 78 patients, 75 (96%) achieved sufficient vertigo control to avoid ablative surgery, and 42 (54%) required only one round. Thirty-six (46%) required multiple rounds. The probability of needing another round increased with each subsequent one, through four rounds. The median times to the next round after one, two, or three rounds were 148, 118, and 124 days, respectively.
More than half of patients need only one round of IT gentamicin injections. With each additional round through the fourth one, the probability of additional rounds increases. Nevertheless, the majority (96%) of patients do not need ablative surgery after IT gentamicin.
目的/假设:采用低剂量和滴定方案时,后续进行鼓室内(IT)庆大霉素注射对于梅尼埃病眩晕的控制常常是必要的。迄今为止,研究尚未对复发性眩晕的时间进程和重复注射进行详细描述。我们的目标是通过Kaplan-Meier生存分析提供这样的描述,这可能有助于准确预测在给定时间或注射次数后复发性眩晕的概率。
对单侧明确的梅尼埃病患者进行IT庆大霉素注射。在6周内注射一次(或很少超过一次)构成一个“疗程”。当需要控制复发性眩晕时进行重复疗程。
我们使用Kaplan-Meier方法对8年期间眩晕得到控制的患者百分比进行量化。为每个疗程数创建一条单独的曲线,每个疗程的失败定义为需要额外进行一个疗程。
78例患者中,75例(96%)实现了足够的眩晕控制,从而避免了破坏性手术,42例(54%)仅需要一个疗程。36例(46%)需要多个疗程。在四个疗程中,每进行一个后续疗程,需要再进行一个疗程的概率都会增加。在进行一个、两个或三个疗程后,到下一个疗程的中位时间分别为148天、118天和124天。
超过一半的患者仅需要一轮IT庆大霉素注射。在进行到第四个疗程之前,每增加一个疗程,需要额外疗程的概率就会增加。然而,大多数(96%)患者在接受IT庆大霉素治疗后不需要进行破坏性手术。