O'Connor Chris, Adhikari Neill K J, DeCaire Katharine, Friedrich Jan O
Department of Medicine, Trillium Health Centre, Mississauga, Ontario, Canada.
J Hosp Med. 2009 Feb;4(2):81-9. doi: 10.1002/jhm.399.
The value of order sets for clinical decision support has not been established.
To determine whether introduction of admission order sets increases the proportion of inpatients receiving deep venous thrombosis (DVT) prophylaxis.
Before-after study.
Community hospital.
General medical patients admitted to hospital.
Paper-based admission order sets (instead of free-text orders) for voluntary use by internists, without any education or behavior change interventions.
Primary outcome was proportion of medical admissions ordered DVT prophylaxis. Secondary outcomes included overall utilization of DVT prophylaxis in medical inpatients and other admission order care quality measures.
Prior to introduction of order sets, DVT prophylaxis was ordered in 10.9% of patients. Patients admitted with order sets were more likely to be ordered DVT prophylaxis than patients admitted with free-text orders (44.0% versus 20.6%, by months 14 and 15, P<0.0001). Hospital-wide DVT prophylaxis in medical inpatients increased from 12.8% to 25.8% of patient-days (P<0.0001). Order set use improved many other secondary outcomes (P<0.05 for all), including allied health consultations (62.8% versus 12.7%), use of standardized diabetic diet (17.0% versus 5.1%), insulin sliding scale (19.1% versus 7.6%), potassium replacement protocol (63.8% versus 0.51%), documentation of allergies (54.3% versus 9.6%) and resuscitation status (57.4% versus 10.2%), and reduced orders for inappropriate laboratory tests such as blood urea nitrogen (39.4% versus 59.0%).
The broad impact of order sets and minimal organizational resources required for their implementation suggests that order sets may have wide applicability as a clinical decision support tool.
临床决策支持医嘱集的价值尚未确定。
确定引入入院医嘱集是否会增加接受深静脉血栓形成(DVT)预防的住院患者比例。
前后对照研究。
社区医院。
入院的普通内科患者。
供内科医生自愿使用的纸质入院医嘱集(而非自由文本医嘱),未进行任何教育或行为改变干预。
主要结局是接受DVT预防医嘱的内科入院患者比例。次要结局包括内科住院患者中DVT预防的总体使用率以及其他入院医嘱护理质量指标。
在引入医嘱集之前,10.9%的患者接受了DVT预防医嘱。使用医嘱集入院的患者比使用自由文本医嘱入院的患者更有可能接受DVT预防医嘱(到第14和15个月时,分别为44.0%和20.6%,P<0.0001)。内科住院患者全院范围的DVT预防从患者住院日的12.8%增加到25.8%(P<0.0001)。医嘱集的使用改善了许多其他次要结局(所有P<0.05),包括联合健康咨询(62.8%对12.7%)、标准化糖尿病饮食的使用(17.0%对5.1%)、胰岛素调整剂量(19.1%对7.6%)、补钾方案(63.8%对0.51%)、过敏记录(54.3%对9.6%)和复苏状态记录(57.4%对10.2%),并减少了如血尿素氮等不适当实验室检查的医嘱(39.4%对59.0%)。
医嘱集的广泛影响及其实施所需的最少组织资源表明,医嘱集作为一种临床决策支持工具可能具有广泛的适用性。