Miller Jonathan P, Magill Stephen T, Acar Feridun, Burchiel Kim J
Department of Neurological Surgery, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, Oregon, USA.
J Neurosurg. 2009 Apr;110(4):620-6. doi: 10.3171/2008.9.17660.
Microvascular decompression (MVD) is an effective treatment for trigeminal neuralgia (TN). However, many patients do not experience complete pain relief, and relapse can occur even after an initial excellent result. This study was designed to identify characteristics associated with improved long-term outcome after MVD.
One hundred seventy-nine consecutive patients who had undergone MVD for TN at the authors' institution were contacted, and 95 were enrolled in the study. Patients provided information about preoperative pain characteristics including preponderance of shock-like (Type 1 TN) or constant (Type 2 TN) pain, preoperative duration, trigger points, anticonvulsant therapy response, memorable onset, and pain-free intervals. Three groups were defined based on outcome: 1) excellent, pain relief without medication; 2) good, mild or intermittent pain controlled with low-dose medication; and 3) poor, severe persistent pain or need for additional surgical treatment. Results Type of TN pain (Type 1 TN vs Type 2 TN) was the only significant predictor of outcome after MVD.
were excellent, good, and poor for Type 1 TN versus Type 2 TN patients in 60 versus 25%, 24 versus 39%, and 16 versus 36%, respectively. Among patients with each TN type, there was a significant trend toward better outcome with greater proportional contribution of Type 1 TN (lancinating) symptoms (p < 0.05).
Pain relief after MVD is strongly correlated with the lancinating pain component, and therefore type of TN pain is the best predictor of long-term outcome after MVD. Application of this information should be helpful in the selection of TN patients likely to benefit from MVD.
微血管减压术(MVD)是治疗三叉神经痛(TN)的一种有效方法。然而,许多患者并未实现完全的疼痛缓解,甚至在最初取得良好效果后仍可能复发。本研究旨在确定与微血管减压术后长期疗效改善相关的特征。
联系了在作者所在机构接受过三叉神经痛微血管减压术的179例连续患者,其中95例纳入研究。患者提供了术前疼痛特征的信息,包括电击样(1型TN)或持续性(2型TN)疼痛的优势、术前病程、触发点、抗惊厥治疗反应、难忘的发病情况以及无痛间歇期。根据结果定义了三组:1)优秀,无需药物即可缓解疼痛;2)良好,低剂量药物可控制轻度或间歇性疼痛;3)差,严重持续性疼痛或需要额外的手术治疗。结果TN疼痛类型(1型TN与2型TN)是微血管减压术后结果的唯一显著预测因素。
1型TN患者与2型TN患者的结果分别为优秀、良好和差,比例分别为60%对25%、24%对39%、16%对36%。在每种TN类型的患者中,1型TN(刺痛)症状的比例贡献越大,预后越好的趋势越显著(p<0.05)。
微血管减压术后的疼痛缓解与刺痛性疼痛成分密切相关,因此TN疼痛类型是微血管减压术后长期疗效的最佳预测因素。应用这些信息应有助于选择可能从微血管减压术中获益的TN患者。