Fortuna Robert J, Palfrey Judith S, Shelov Steven P, Samuels Ronald C
Department of Ambulatory Care and Prevention, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02215, USA.
J Eval Clin Pract. 2009 Feb;15(1):116-20. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2753.2008.00964.x.
To evaluate the perceived impact of work-hour limitations on paediatric residency training programmes and to determine the various strategies used to accommodate these restrictions.
A three-page pre-tested survey was administered to programme directors at the 2004 Association of Paediatric Programme Directors meeting. The impact of work-hours was evaluated with Likert-type questions and the methods used to meet work-hour requirements were compared between large programmes (>or=30 residents) and small programmes.
Surveys were received from 53 programme directors. The majority responded that work-hour limitations negatively impacted inpatient continuity, time for education, schedule flexibility and attending staff satisfaction. Supervision by attending staff was the only aspect to significantly improve. Perceived resident satisfaction was neutral. To accommodate work-hour limitations, 64% of programmes increased clinical responsibility to existing non-resident staff, 36% hired more non-resident staff and 17% increased the number of residents. Only one programme hired additional non-clinical staff. Large programmes were more likely to use more total methods on the inpatient wards (P < 0.01) and in the intensive care units (P < 0.05) to accommodate work-hour limitations.
Programme directors perceived a negative impact of work-hours on most aspects of training without a perceived difference in resident satisfaction. While a variety of methods are used to accommodate work-hour limitations, programmes are not widely utilizing non-clinical staff to alleviate clerical burdens.
评估工作时间限制对儿科住院医师培训项目的感知影响,并确定用于适应这些限制的各种策略。
在2004年儿科项目主任协会会议上,向项目主任发放了一份经过预测试的三页调查问卷。通过李克特式问题评估工作时间的影响,并比较大型项目(≥30名住院医师)和小型项目为满足工作时间要求所采用的方法。
收到了53位项目主任的调查问卷。大多数人回应称,工作时间限制对住院患者的连续性、教育时间、日程灵活性和主治 staff 的满意度产生了负面影响。主治 staff 的监督是唯一显著改善的方面。住院医师的感知满意度为中性。为适应工作时间限制,64%的项目增加了现有非住院医师 staff 的临床职责,36%雇佣了更多非住院医师 staff,17%增加了住院医师人数。只有一个项目雇佣了额外的非临床 staff。大型项目更有可能在住院病房(P < 0.01)和重症监护病房(P < 0.05)采用更多总体方法来适应工作时间限制。
项目主任认为工作时间对培训的大多数方面有负面影响,而住院医师的满意度没有明显差异。虽然采用了多种方法来适应工作时间限制,但项目并未广泛利用非临床 staff 来减轻文书工作负担。