Hummel J D, Dosdall L M, Clayton G W, Harker K N, O'Donovan J T
Department of Agricultural, Food and Nutritional Science, 4-10 Agriculture/Forestry Centre, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada T6G 2P5.
J Econ Entomol. 2009 Feb;102(1):219-28. doi: 10.1603/029.102.0131.
Reductions in oviposition and subsequent damage by root maggots (Diptera: Anthomyiidae, Delia spp.) to brassicaceous crops in the presence of nonhost plants has been demonstrated, but such investigations have not been conducted using intercrops of species commonly grown in the large-scale agricultural production systems of western Canada. A field experiment was conducted at three sites in Alberta, Canada, in 2005 and 2006 to determine interactions between root maggots and the various proportions of canola (Brassica napus L.) making up the total crop plant populations in intercrops with wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). The effect of a neonicotinoid seed treatment also was investigated. Root maggot damage to canola taproots decreased with increasing proportions of wheat in the intercrops. The presence of wheat in the intercrops had little effect on root maggot adult abundance in any single site-by-year combination or when data were combined over all sites and years, with different Delia species and sexes responding differently. Similarly, per plant root maggot egg populations were unaffected by intercropping, although egg populations were reduced on a per unit land area basis in intercrops compared with monocultures. Insecticidal seed treatment did not affect root maggot egg populations or canola root damage. Variable abundances and phenologies of the principal root maggot species infesting canola at different sites and years may influence their responses to canola-wheat intercrops. Intercropping canola and wheat may provide an opportunity for reducing crop damage from root maggot attack without compromising environmental sustainability.
在非寄主植物存在的情况下,根蛆(双翅目:花蝇科,地种蝇属)对十字花科作物的产卵量及后续危害已有所减少,但尚未针对加拿大西部大规模农业生产系统中常见的间作作物进行此类研究。2005年和2006年,在加拿大艾伯塔省的三个地点进行了一项田间试验,以确定根蛆与不同比例的油菜(甘蓝型油菜)之间的相互作用,这些油菜与小麦(普通小麦)构成了间作作物中的总作物种群。同时还研究了新烟碱类种子处理的效果。随着间作中小麦比例的增加,根蛆对油菜主根的危害程度降低。间作中的小麦对任何单个地点-年份组合或所有地点和年份的数据合并后的根蛆成虫数量影响不大,不同的地种蝇种类和性别反应不同。同样,每株植物上的根蛆卵数量不受间作影响,尽管与单作相比,间作中单位土地面积上的卵数量有所减少。杀虫种子处理对根蛆卵数量或油菜根损伤没有影响。在不同地点和年份,侵染油菜的主要根蛆种类的丰度和物候期各不相同,这可能会影响它们对油菜-小麦间作的反应。间作油菜和小麦可能为减少根蛆对作物的危害提供机会,同时又不损害环境可持续性。