Gunderson Leonard L, Callister Matthew, Marschke Robert, Young-Fadok Tonia, Heppell Jacques, Efron Jonathan
Division of Medical Oncology, Mayo Clinic Cancer Center-Arizona Scottsdale, AZ.
Gastrointest Cancer Res. 2008 Jan;2(1):25-33.
Disease relapse (local, distant) and survival rates (overall [OS], disease-free [DFS]) are dependent on disease stage at time of diagnosis. In rectal cancer pooled analyses of phase III North American trials, OS and DFS were dependent on TN stage (N substage within T stage), NT stage (T substage within N stage), and treatment method. Three risk groups of patients were defined: (1) intermediate T1-2N1, T3N0; (2) moderately high T1-2N2, T3N1, T4N0; and (3) high T3N2, T4N1, T4N2. Patients with a single high-risk factor (T1-2N1, T3N0) were shown to have better OS, DFS, and disease control than patients with both high-risk factors. Although adjuvant chemoradiotherapy (CRT) is indicated for patients with moderately high-risk and high-risk stage of disease, many of these patients are currently treated preoperatively if stage of disease can be defined. If surgery precedes adjuvant treatment, however, postoperative CRT is certainly indicated for these risk groups. For patients with intermediate-risk stage of disease (T1-2N1, T3N0), use of trimodality treatment (surgery plus radiotherapy and chemotherapy) in all patients may be excessive. The challenge is in determining which patients can be spared adjuvant CRT and whether it is worth the exercise.
疾病复发(局部、远处)和生存率(总生存率[OS]、无病生存率[DFS])取决于诊断时的疾病分期。在北美III期试验的直肠癌汇总分析中,OS和DFS取决于TN分期(T分期内的N亚分期)、NT分期(N分期内的T亚分期)以及治疗方法。定义了三组风险患者:(1)中度风险T1-2N1、T3N0;(2)中度高风险T1-2N2、T3N1、T4N0;(3)高风险T3N2、T4N1、T4N2。与具有两个高风险因素的患者相比,具有单个高风险因素(T1-2N1、T3N0)的患者显示出更好的OS、DFS和疾病控制。虽然辅助放化疗(CRT)适用于中度高风险和高风险疾病阶段的患者,但如果可以确定疾病分期,目前许多此类患者在术前接受治疗。然而,如果手术在辅助治疗之前进行,对于这些风险组患者,术后CRT肯定是必要的。对于中度风险疾病阶段(T1-2N1、T3N0)的患者,对所有患者使用三联疗法(手术加放疗和化疗)可能过度。挑战在于确定哪些患者可以免于辅助CRT以及这样做是否值得。