McNickle Gordon G, Cahill James F
Department of Biological Sciences, University of Alberta, CW 405, Biological Sciences Centre, Edmonton, AB, Canada T6G 2E9.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009 Mar 24;106(12):4747-51. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0807971106. Epub 2009 Mar 5.
All organisms must find and consume resources to live, and the strategies an organism uses when foraging can have significant impacts on their fitness. Models assuming optimality in foraging behavior, and which quantitatively account for the costs, benefits, and biological constraints of foraging, are common in the animal literature. Plant ecologists on the other hand have rarely adopted an explicit framework of optimality with respect to plant root foraging. Here, we show with a simple experiment that the marginal value theorem (MVT), one of the most classic models of animal foraging behavior, can provide novel insights into the root foraging behavior of plants. We also discuss existing data in the literature, which has not usually been linked to MVT to provide further support for the benefits of an optimal foraging framework for plants. As predicted by MVT, plants invest more time and effort into highly enriched patches than they do to low-enriched patches. On the basis of this congruency, and the recent calls for new directions in the plant foraging literature, we suggest plant ecologists should work toward a more explicit treatment of the idea of optimality in studies of plant root foraging. Such an approach is advantageous because it forces a quantitative treatment of the assumptions being made and the constraints on the system. While we believe significant insight can be gained from the use of preexisting models of animal foraging, ultimately plant ecologists will have to develop taxa-specific models that account for the unique biology of plants.
所有生物都必须寻找并消耗资源以维持生存,而生物在觅食时所采用的策略会对其适合度产生重大影响。在动物学文献中,假设觅食行为具有最优性并定量考虑觅食成本、收益及生物学限制的模型很常见。另一方面,植物生态学家很少采用关于植物根系觅食的明确最优框架。在此,我们通过一个简单实验表明,动物觅食行为最经典的模型之一——边际价值定理(MVT),能够为植物根系觅食行为提供全新见解。我们还讨论了文献中的现有数据,这些数据通常未与MVT相关联,以进一步支持最优觅食框架对植物的益处。正如MVT所预测的,植物在高富集斑块上投入的时间和精力比在低富集斑块上更多。基于这种一致性,以及近期植物觅食文献中对新方向的呼吁,我们建议植物生态学家在植物根系觅食研究中应朝着更明确地处理最优性概念的方向努力。这种方法具有优势,因为它促使对所做假设和系统限制进行定量处理。虽然我们认为使用现有的动物觅食模型能获得重要见解,但最终植物生态学家将不得不开发考虑植物独特生物学特性的特定分类群模型。