Been H D
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Academical Medical Centre Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Acta Orthop Belg. 1991;57 Suppl 1:144-61.
A retrospective study was performed on 62 patients treated for thoracolumbar burst fractures. The Fracture Study Protocol of the Scoliosis Research Society was used for data collection. The first group consisted of 29 patients, treated between July 1983 and November 1986 with an one-stage operation consisting of anterior decompression by subtotal vertebrectomy, reduction and stabilization with the Slot-Zielke device. The mean follow-up was 3.1 years. The second group consisted of 33 patients, who were treated between November 1986 and November 1988. In this second group treatment was performed by an anterior decompression by subtotal vertebrectomy, reduction and stabilization with the Slot-Zielke-device, in the same session followed by an additional posterior spondylodesis and instrumentation with the Zielke D.K.S.-system or by the Cotrel-Dubousset compression-rod system. Mean follow-up of this second group was 1.7 years. In all patients bony union occurred. Loss of reduction of more than 5 degrees occurred in 41% of the patients of the first group, but in only one patient (3%) of the second group. In both groups most patients with incomplete neurologic lesions improved postoperatively and were upgraded one or two steps on the Frankel-scale. No patient showed neurologic deterioration after surgery. In both groups a high percentage of patients were painfree at follow-up. The complication rate in both groups was low, despite the rather difficult anterior approach. Because of the high rate of loss of reduction in the first group of 29 patients and the low degree of flexion-bending loading and torsional stability in biomechanical evaluation in vitro of the Slot-Zielke device on human cadaver spine, an additional posterior stabilization of the spine after an anterior approach for anterior- and middle-column fractures should be considered.
对62例胸腰椎爆裂骨折患者进行了回顾性研究。采用脊柱侧弯研究学会的骨折研究方案收集数据。第一组由29例患者组成,于1983年7月至1986年11月接受一期手术治疗,手术包括经椎体次全切除进行前路减压、使用Slot-Zielke器械进行复位和固定。平均随访时间为3.1年。第二组由33例患者组成,于1986年11月至1988年11月接受治疗。在第二组中,通过经椎体次全切除进行前路减压、使用Slot-Zielke器械进行复位和固定,在同一会期中随后进行额外的后路脊柱融合术,并使用Zielke D.K.S.系统或Cotrel-Dubousset加压棒系统进行器械固定。第二组的平均随访时间为1.7年。所有患者均实现了骨愈合。第一组41%的患者出现了超过5度的复位丢失,但第二组只有1例患者(3%)出现这种情况。两组中大多数不完全神经损伤患者术后病情改善,在Frankel分级上提高了一到两级。术后无患者出现神经功能恶化。两组中均有很高比例的患者在随访时无疼痛。尽管前路手术相当困难,但两组的并发症发生率都很低。由于第一组29例患者的复位丢失率较高,且Slot-Zielke器械在人体尸体脊柱体外生物力学评估中的屈伸加载和扭转稳定性较低,对于前柱和中柱骨折,在进行前路手术之后应考虑额外进行脊柱后路稳定手术。