Laxman Vandana K, Khatri Manish, Devaraj C G, Reddy Kranti, Reddy Ramesh
Department of Periodontics, College of Dental Sciences, Davangere, Karnataka, India
J Contemp Dent Pract. 2009 Mar 1;10(2):18-25.
To date probing of the furcation using sounding has been one of the reliable methods to assess horizontal component of furcation in multirooted teeth. A more precise and reliable measurement of this horizontal component of furcation involves using a fixed reference point providing stability and reproducibility of measurements. A custom stent is used to provide a fixed reference point and can be used pre- and post-surgically without re-entry. Therefore, the purposes of this study were to (1) assess the reliability of furcation measurements by direct probing (without stent) and with the use of a newly designed furcation stent and (2) to assess the furcation measurements in relation to gingival margin position pre- and post-operatively.
Forty-three chronic periodontitis patients with buccal grade II furcation involvement in maxillary or mandibular molars were included. The furcation involvement was measured by direct probing using a UNC-15 calibrated probe with and without using a custom stent. The furcation involvement and gingival margin position were measured pre- and post-surgically.
There was a significant reduction in plaque (PI) and gingival inflammation (GI) during the study period. The reduction in plaque index and gingival index was observed from 1.75 +/- 0.35 to 0.92 +/- 0.30, 1.88 +/- 0.35 to 0.98 +/- 0.29, respectively. Complete agreement was found between the first and the second measurement for about 74% of sites without the custom stent, whereas 86% of the sites measured using the stent had complete agreement. The differences never exceeded 1 mm for any of the sites. There was significant (t = 2.49; p<0.05) difference observed at complete agreement level ('0' difference).
It may be concluded the clinical attachment level-H of the furcation involvement using a PCP UNC-15 probe and a custom designed stent provides reproducible information about the furcation depth in multirooted teeth.
Use of a simple modified furcation stent has shown greater reproducibility of furcal depth measurements than direct probing without the stent. The furcation stent definitely addresses the problems of existing methods of horizontal furcal depth measurements reported in the literature. The major advantages of the newly designed stent are the simple construction and non-invasive application which translates to wide practical applications.
迄今为止,使用探针探测根分叉是评估多根牙根分叉水平分量的可靠方法之一。对根分叉水平分量进行更精确可靠的测量需要使用固定参考点,以确保测量的稳定性和可重复性。定制支架可提供固定参考点,可在手术前后使用,无需再次进入。因此,本研究的目的是:(1)评估直接探查(不使用支架)和使用新设计的根分叉支架进行根分叉测量的可靠性;(2)评估手术前后根分叉测量与牙龈边缘位置的关系。
纳入43例患有上颌或下颌磨牙颊侧II度根分叉病变的慢性牙周炎患者。使用UNC-15校准探针,在使用和不使用定制支架的情况下,通过直接探查测量根分叉病变。在手术前后测量根分叉病变和牙龈边缘位置。
在研究期间,菌斑(PI)和牙龈炎症(GI)显著减少。菌斑指数和牙龈指数分别从1.75±0.35降至0.92±0.30、从1.88±0.35降至0.98±0.29。在约74%未使用定制支架的部位,第一次和第二次测量完全一致;而使用支架测量的部位中,86%完全一致。任何部位的差异均未超过1毫米。在完全一致水平(“0”差异)观察到显著差异(t = 2.49;p<0.05)。
可以得出结论,使用PCP UNC-15探针和定制设计的支架测量根分叉病变的临床附着水平-H,可为多根牙根分叉深度提供可重复的信息。
使用简单改良的根分叉支架比不使用支架的直接探查在测量根分叉深度方面具有更高的可重复性。根分叉支架确实解决了文献中报道的现有水平根分叉深度测量方法的问题。新设计支架的主要优点是结构简单、应用无创,这使其具有广泛的实际应用价值。