Shiely F, MacDonncha C
Department of Epidemiology and Public Health, University College Cork, Brookfield Health Sciences Complex, College Road, Cork.
Ir Med J. 2009 Jan;102(1):15-9.
Objectively measured and self-reported physical activity levels were assessed among Irish adolescents (n=28) by heart rate monitor and self-report questionnaire. The purpose was to determine the percentage of Irish adolescents that met international physical activity guidelines using both objective and subjective measurements. More than 11% of subjects met the international moderate intensity physical activity guidelines for adolescents when measured by self-report questionnaire. No subjects met this guideline when measured objectively by heart rate monitor. Levels of agreement between the two measurements were poor (k < 0.40). When measured objectively by HR monitor, no adolescent met the international guidelines on sustained vigorous physical activity. Prevalence estimates for compliance with international physical activity guidelines varied according to mode of measurement. We conclude that compared to self-report measures, adolescent physical activity levels are lower than those required for health benefits when measured objectively, and only a minority of young people satisfy the international recommendations.
通过心率监测器和自我报告问卷,对爱尔兰青少年(n = 28)的客观测量和自我报告的身体活动水平进行了评估。目的是确定使用客观和主观测量方法达到国际身体活动指南的爱尔兰青少年的百分比。通过自我报告问卷测量时,超过11%的受试者达到了青少年国际中等强度身体活动指南。通过心率监测器进行客观测量时,没有受试者达到该指南。两种测量方法之间的一致性水平较差(k < 0.40)。通过心率监测器进行客观测量时,没有青少年达到国际持续剧烈身体活动指南。符合国际身体活动指南的患病率估计因测量方式而异。我们得出结论,与自我报告测量相比,客观测量时青少年的身体活动水平低于对健康有益所需的水平,只有少数年轻人符合国际建议。