Jamjoom A A B, Nikkar-Esfahani A, Fitzgerald J E F
University of Nottingham Medical School, Queen's Medical Centre, UK.
BMC Med Educ. 2009 Mar 10;9:14. doi: 10.1186/1472-6920-9-14.
Observing surgical procedures is a beneficial educational experience for medical students during their surgical placements. Anecdotal evidence suggests that operating theatre related syncope may have detrimental effects on students' views of this. Our study examines the frequency and causes of such syncope, together with effects on career intentions, and practical steps to avoid its occurrence.
All penultimate and final year students at a large UK medical school were surveyed using the University IT system supplemented by personal approach. A 20-item anonymous questionnaire was distributed and results were analysed using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences, version 15.0 (Chicago, Illinois, USA).
Of the 630 clinical students surveyed, 77 responded with details of at least one near or actual operating theatre syncope (12%). A statistically significant gender difference existed for syncopal/near-syncopal episodes (male 12%; female 88%), p < 0.05. Twenty-two percent of those affected were graduate entry medical course students with the remaining 78% undergraduate. Mean age was 23-years (range 20 - 45). Of the 77 reactors, 44 (57%) reported an intention to pursue a surgical career. Of this group, 7 (9%) reported being discouraged by syncopal episodes in the operating theatre. The most prevalent contributory factors were reported as hot temperature (n = 61, 79%), prolonged standing (n = 56, 73%), wearing a surgical mask (n = 36, 47%) and the smell of diathermy (n = 18, 23%). The most frequently reported measures that students found helpful in reducing the occurrence of syncopal episodes were eating and drinking prior to attending theatre (n = 47, 61%), and moving their legs whilst standing (n = 14, 18%).
Our study shows that operating theatre related syncope among medical students is common, and we establish useful risk factors and practical steps that have been used to prevent its occurrence. Our study also highlights the detrimental effect of this on the career intentions of medical students interested in surgery. Based on these findings, we recommend that dedicated time should be set aside in surgical teaching to address this issue prior to students attending the operating theatre.
对于医学生而言,在外科实习期间观摩手术过程是一种有益的学习经历。轶事证据表明,与手术室相关的晕厥可能会对学生对此的看法产生不利影响。我们的研究调查了此类晕厥的发生频率和原因,以及对职业意向的影响,还有避免其发生的实际措施。
通过英国一所大型医学院的大学信息技术系统,并辅以个人走访的方式,对所有大二和大五学生进行了调查。发放了一份包含20个条目的匿名问卷,并使用社会科学统计软件包第15.0版(美国伊利诺伊州芝加哥)对结果进行分析。
在接受调查的630名临床学生中,77人详细回复了至少一次接近或实际发生在手术室的晕厥情况(12%)。晕厥/接近晕厥发作存在统计学上显著的性别差异(男性12%;女性88%),p < 0.05。受影响的学生中,22%是研究生入学医学课程的学生,其余78%是本科生。平均年龄为23岁(范围20 - 45岁)。在77名有反应的学生中,44人(57%)表示有意从事外科职业。在这一组中,7人(9%)表示手术室的晕厥发作使他们打消了念头。报告的最常见促成因素依次为温度高(n = 61,79%)、长时间站立(n = 56,73%)、佩戴外科口罩(n = 36,47%)和电刀气味(n = 18,2,3%)。学生们发现最有助于减少晕厥发作的措施依次为进手术室前饮食(n = 47,61%)以及站立时活动腿部(n = 14,18%)。
我们的研究表明,医学生中与手术室相关的晕厥很常见,我们确定了有用的风险因素和用于预防其发生的实际措施。我们的研究还突出了这对有志于外科手术的医学生职业意向的不利影响。基于这些发现,我们建议在外科教学中应专门留出时间,在学生进入手术室之前解决这个问题。