Nguyen-Michel V H, Ourabah Z, Sebban C, Lavallard-Rousseau M-C, Adam C
Services d'explorations fonctionnelles et de gériatrie, hôpital Charles-Foix, AP-HP, Ivry-sur-Seine, France.
Rev Neurol (Paris). 2009 Nov;165(11):924-32. doi: 10.1016/j.neurol.2009.01.042. Epub 2009 Mar 13.
Long-term follow-up studies indicate a low remission rate in idiopathic generalised epilepsies (IGE) (Martinez-Juarez et al., 2006), suggesting they may persist to an advanced age. However there are few estimates of IGE frequency in the elderly.
EEGs of 700 patients aged over 70 years, recorded between January 2006 and March 2007, were reviewed for anomalies consistent with IGE. We then examined the clinical history of patients with these anomalies.
A persistent IGE was identified in four female patients (mean age: 79 years); in two cases it was a juvenile myoclonic epilepsy (JME) and in two an epilepsy with grand mal seizures. Seizures in three patients had begun in childhood or adolescence and in one at 40 years. Before hospitalization, few or no seizures were reported and IGE had not been diagnosed. IGE was revealed in each patient by a relatively severe event: an absence status (AS), subcontinuous myoclonic seizures or repeated convulsive generalised seizures (CGS). These events were not situation-related but in one patient the relapse of simple convulsive seizures, may have been related to the withdrawal of anti-epileptic drugs (AED) several months previously. EEG records showed generalised spikes or polyspikes and waves organised in a status epilepticus or in interictal rhythmic discharges. In one case they were evident only from a 24 hours recording. Clonazepam injection was used to suppress the AS episode and the subintrant myoclonia. After the AS, interictal generalised epileptic discharges persisted. Two of the four patients had familial history of epilepsy or febrile seizures but in no case was an epileptogenic lesion evident in brain CT scan or MRI. Clinical exams and biologic parameters were normal. All of the patients had worked and were married with children. Appropriate therapies were followed after the diagnosis of IGE. One patient with JME had been treated by Valproate which was discontinued by the general practitioner because of lethargy and replaced by Carbamazepine; seizures were aggravated under both Carbamazepine and then Lamotrigine and until the patient became seizure-free on Levetiracetam. The antiepiletic treatment was also modified in a second patient, while the two others responded well to Valproate.
IGE can exacerbate in the elderly, as different types of seizures including AS, subintrant myoclonia or repeated CGS. Our data suggest persistent IGE are quite frequent in an aged population and may be underestimated due to difficulties in diagnosis. Correctly diagnosed, adjustment of AED may offer substantial clinical improvements in IGE of the elderly.
长期随访研究表明,特发性全身性癫痫(IGE)的缓解率较低(Martinez-Juarez等人,2006年),这表明它们可能持续到高龄。然而,关于老年人中IGE发病率的估计很少。
回顾了2006年1月至2007年3月期间记录的700名70岁以上患者的脑电图,以查找与IGE一致的异常情况。然后我们检查了有这些异常情况的患者的临床病史。
在4名女性患者(平均年龄:79岁)中发现了持续性IGE;其中2例为青少年肌阵挛性癫痫(JME),2例为伴有大发作的癫痫。3例患者的癫痫发作始于儿童期或青春期,1例始于40岁。在住院前,很少或没有报告癫痫发作,且未诊断出IGE。每位患者均因相对严重的事件而被发现患有IGE:失神状态(AS)、亚持续性肌阵挛发作或反复惊厥性全身性发作(CGS)。这些事件与情境无关,但在1例患者中,单纯惊厥性发作的复发可能与几个月前停用抗癫痫药物(AED)有关。脑电图记录显示有全身性棘波或多棘波以及在癫痫持续状态或发作间期节律性放电中出现的波。在1例病例中,它们仅在24小时记录中明显。使用氯硝西泮注射来抑制AS发作和亚持续性肌阵挛。AS发作后,发作间期全身性癫痫放电持续存在。4名患者中有2名有癫痫或热性惊厥家族史,但在任何病例中,脑CT扫描或MRI均未发现致痫性病变。临床检查和生物学参数均正常。所有患者都有工作,已婚并有子女。在诊断出IGE后采用了适当的治疗方法。1例JME患者曾接受丙戊酸盐治疗,由于嗜睡,全科医生停用了该药物,改用卡马西平;在卡马西平和随后的拉莫三嗪治疗下癫痫发作均加重,直到患者在左乙拉西坦治疗下无癫痫发作。第二名患者的抗癫痫治疗也进行了调整,而另外两名患者对丙戊酸盐反应良好。
IGE在老年人中可能会加重,表现为不同类型的发作,包括AS、亚持续性肌阵挛或反复CGS。我们的数据表明,持续性IGE在老年人群中相当常见,可能由于诊断困难而被低估。正确诊断后,调整AED可能会使老年IGE患者的临床状况有显著改善。