Xu Yan, Ao Ying-fang
Institute of Sports Medicine of Peking University Third Hospital, 100191, Beijing, China.
Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2009 Jul;17(7):770-7. doi: 10.1007/s00167-009-0764-6. Epub 2009 Mar 21.
In order to observe the remodeling process of the inter-strand of the four-strand graft used for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, and to find the histological and biomechanical influences on this process by braiding the four-strand graft, we conducted this study in a rabbit model. The rabbit's ACLs were reconstructed with bilateral four-strand semitendinous tendons which are in parallel or braided shape. The specimens of the two groups were collected at 3, 6, 12, 26 and 52 weeks after the operation. Gross and histological observations were done and the biomechanical properties of the specimens of the 26 and 52 weeks were compared. The result showed that in regular group, at 3 weeks, the strands which were in necrosis status were still separated with each other. At 6 weeks, the grafts were enveloped with hyperplastic synovium, some outer part of the gaps between strands were filled with synovium and fused together, while the inner parts were still separated. At 12 weeks, the graft was still in remodeling progress, but the remodeling degrees of each strand were different. Some strands had fused but some were still separated with "big" interval. At 26 and 52 weeks, some inter-strand gaps were hard to discriminate, some strands were connected with connective tissue and some separated ones still showed up. The braided ones manifested a similar but more synchronized remodeling process and showed a higher inter-strands fusing rate. The biomechanical test showed that the strength of the reconstructed ACL of the regular unbraided tendons was 36% of the contralateral normal ACL, while the braided ones reached 67%. The graft strengths of the specimen of the 26 and 52 weeks in the braided graft group were significantly higher than that of the unbraided group, while the stiffness of the 52-week specimen of the braided group was significantly higher than that of the unbraided group also. From this study, we concluded that as a graft for reconstruction of the ACL, the four-strand hamstring tendon needs to pass through the necrosis, revascularization, and ligamentation progress, but different strands were not in a synchronous process. The inter-strand gap may be completely fused, partial fused, fused but connected with connective tissue or still separated. By braiding the strands, the fusing percentage of the graft could be elevated and the biomechanical properties could be improved.
为观察用于前交叉韧带(ACL)重建的四股移植物股间的重塑过程,并探究编织四股移植物对该过程的组织学和生物力学影响,我们在兔模型上开展了本研究。用双侧平行或编织状的四股半腱肌腱重建兔的ACL。在术后3、6、12、26和52周收集两组的标本。进行大体和组织学观察,并比较26周和52周标本的生物力学特性。结果显示,在常规组中,3周时,处于坏死状态的股束仍相互分离。6周时,移植物被增生的滑膜包裹,股束间一些间隙的外部被滑膜填充并融合在一起,而内部仍分离。12周时,移植物仍处于重塑过程,但各股束的重塑程度不同。一些股束已融合,但一些仍以“较大”间隙分离。在26周和52周时,一些股间间隙难以区分,一些股束与结缔组织相连,一些分离的股束仍然存在。编织组表现出相似但更同步的重塑过程,且股间融合率更高。生物力学测试表明,常规未编织肌腱重建的ACL强度为对侧正常ACL的36%,而编织肌腱重建的ACL强度达到67%。编织移植物组26周和52周标本的移植物强度显著高于未编织组,编织组52周标本的刚度也显著高于未编织组。从本研究中,我们得出结论,作为ACL重建的移植物,四股腘绳肌腱需要经历坏死、血管再生和韧带化过程,但不同股束并非同步进行。股间间隙可能完全融合、部分融合、融合但与结缔组织相连或仍分离。通过编织股束,可提高移植物的融合百分比并改善生物力学特性。