Goddard Jerome, deShazo Richard
Department of Entomology and Plant Pathology, Mississippi State University, Box 9775, Mississippi State, MS 39762, USA.
JAMA. 2009 Apr 1;301(13):1358-66. doi: 10.1001/jama.2009.405.
Bed bug (Cimex lectularius) infestations are rapidly increasing worldwide. Health consequences include nuisance biting and cutaneous and systemic reactions. The potential for bed bugs to serve as disease vectors and optimal methods for bed bug pest control and eradication are unclear.
To present current knowledge of the health and medical effects of bed bugs and to explore key issues in pest control and eradication efforts.
A search of MEDLINE and EMBASE databases (1960-October 2008) for articles using the keywords bed bugs, Cimex lectularius, humans, parasitology, pathogenicity, and drug effects. For pest control, PubMed and Toxline searches (1960-October 2008) were performed using the keywords bed bugs, Cimex, control, prevention, and eradication. Manual searches of older journals, textbooks, pest control trade journals, and newspapers (1892-October 2008) were also performed.
Original accounts or investigations of bed bugs, clinical responses with sufficient detail of cause and effect between the bed bug bite and clinical response, and convincing evidence of substantiated presence of bed bug exposure. For pest control, documentation that an eradication measure quantitatively decreased bed bugs.
A trained medical reference librarian assisted with the literature search. Two authors with expertise in the diagnosis, treatment, and eradication of bed bugs reviewed the clinical articles. One author evaluated the pest control articles.
Fifty-three articles met inclusion criteria and were summarized. Only 2 clinical trials concerning bed bugs were identified and tested the ability of pest control interventions to eradicate bed bugs. Although transmission of more than 40 human diseases has been attributed to bed bugs, there is little evidence that they are vectors of communicable disease. A variety of clinical reactions to bed bugs have been reported, including cutaneous and rarely systemic reactions. A wide range of empirical treatments, including antibiotics, antihistamines, topical and oral corticosteroids, and epinephrine, have been used for bite reactions with varying results. No evidence-based interventions to eradicate bed bugs or prevent bites were identified.
Treatment options for cutaneous and systemic reactions from bed bug bites have not been evaluated in clinical trials and there is no evidence that outcomes differ significantly from those receiving no treatment. Evidence for disease transmission by bed bugs is lacking. Pest control and eradication is challenging due to insecticide resistance, lack of effective products, and health concerns about spraying mattresses with pesticides.
臭虫(温带臭虫)在全球范围内的侵扰正在迅速增加。其对健康的影响包括令人讨厌的叮咬以及皮肤和全身反应。臭虫作为疾病传播媒介的可能性以及臭虫虫害控制和根除的最佳方法尚不清楚。
介绍有关臭虫对健康和医学影响的当前知识,并探讨虫害控制和根除工作中的关键问题。
检索MEDLINE和EMBASE数据库(1960年 - 2008年10月)中使用关键词臭虫、温带臭虫、人类、寄生虫学、致病性和药物作用的文章。对于虫害控制,使用关键词臭虫、臭虫属、控制、预防和根除在PubMed和Toxline中进行检索(1960年 - 2008年10月)。还对手册检索了旧期刊、教科书、虫害控制行业期刊和报纸(1892年 - 2008年10月)。
有关臭虫的原始记录或调查、对臭虫叮咬与临床反应之间因果关系有足够详细描述的临床反应,以及有确凿证据证明存在臭虫暴露。对于虫害控制,有文件证明某种根除措施能使臭虫数量定量减少。
一名经过培训的医学参考馆员协助进行文献检索。两名在臭虫诊断、治疗和根除方面具有专业知识的作者对临床文章进行了综述。一名作者评估了虫害控制文章。
五十三篇文章符合纳入标准并进行了总结。仅确定了两项关于臭虫的临床试验,测试了虫害控制干预措施根除臭虫的能力。尽管有超过40种人类疾病的传播被归因于臭虫,但几乎没有证据表明它们是传染病的传播媒介。已经报道了对臭虫的多种临床反应,包括皮肤反应,很少有全身反应。各种经验性治疗方法,包括抗生素、抗组胺药、局部和口服皮质类固醇以及肾上腺素,已用于叮咬反应,但效果各异。未发现基于证据的根除臭虫或预防叮咬的干预措施。
臭虫叮咬引起的皮肤和全身反应的治疗选择尚未在临床试验中进行评估,并且没有证据表明其结果与未接受治疗的情况有显著差异。缺乏臭虫传播疾病的证据。由于杀虫剂抗性、缺乏有效产品以及对用杀虫剂喷洒床垫的健康担忧,虫害控制和根除具有挑战性。