Krischak Gert D, Krasteva Anna, Schneider Florian, Gulkin Daniel, Gebhard Florian, Kramer Michael
Center of Surgery, Clinic for Traumatology, Hand, Plastic, and Reconstructive Surgery, University of Ulm, Ulm, Germany.
Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2009 Apr;90(4):537-44. doi: 10.1016/j.apmr.2008.09.575.
To determine the effect of 2 different postoperative therapy approaches after operative stabilization of the wrist fractures: treatment by a physical therapist with 12 sessions and an unassisted home exercise program.
Randomized controlled cohort study.
Hospital-based care, primary center of orthopedic surgery.
Volunteers (N=48) with fractures of the distal radius after internal fixation with locking plates. There were 46 patients available for follow-up after exclusion of 2 participants due to physiotherapy sessions in excess of the study protocol.
Not applicable.
Evaluation of grip strength using a Jamar dynamometer, range of motion (ROM), and Patient Related Wrist Evaluation (PRWE).
After a 6-week period of postoperative treatment, the patients (n=23) performing an independent home exercise program using a training diary showed a significantly greater improvement of the functionality of the wrist. Grip strength reached 54% (P=.003), and ROM in extension and flexion 79% (P<.001) of the uninjured side. Ulnar and radial abduction was also higher in this group. In contrast, patients who were treated by a physical therapist achieved grip strength equal to 32%, and ROM in extension and flexion of 52% of the uninjured side. Patients who were performing the home training after operation recorded an improved wrist function with a nearly 50% lower value (P<.001) in the PRWE score.
In the postoperative rehabilitation of wrist fractures, instructions in a home exercise program are an effective alternative to prescribed physical therapy treatment.
确定腕部骨折手术固定后两种不同术后治疗方法的效果:由物理治疗师进行12次治疗以及无辅助的家庭锻炼计划。
随机对照队列研究。
以医院为基础的护理,骨科手术初级中心。
采用锁定钢板内固定治疗桡骨远端骨折的志愿者(N = 48)。排除2名因物理治疗疗程超出研究方案的参与者后,有46名患者可供随访。
不适用。
使用Jamar握力计评估握力、活动范围(ROM)和患者相关腕关节评估(PRWE)。
经过6周的术后治疗,使用训练日记进行独立家庭锻炼计划的患者(n = 23)腕部功能有显著改善。握力达到未受伤侧的54%(P = 0.003),伸展和屈曲活动范围达到未受伤侧的79%(P < 0.001)。该组的尺侧和桡侧外展也更高。相比之下,接受物理治疗师治疗的患者握力等于未受伤侧 的32%,伸展和屈曲活动范围为52%。术后进行家庭训练的患者腕部功能改善,PRWE评分降低近50%(P < 0.001)。
在腕部骨折的术后康复中,家庭锻炼计划指导是规定物理治疗的有效替代方法。