Jančíková V, Opavský J, Dráč P, Krobot A, Čižmář I
Ústav fyzioterapie, Fakulta zdravotnických věd, Univerzita Palackého v Olomouci.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2017;84(2):114-119.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY The aim of the study was to assess the functional outcomes of rehabilitation in patients with surgically treated distal radius fractures in the early postoperative period. We compared the functional outcomes of patients undergoing standard rehabilitation with the group of patients whose postoperative rehabilitation was extended with shoulder girdle exercises of the affected upper limb while the wrist was immobilized. Several indices and variables were used for the assessment of the functional therapeutic outcomes of the affected wrist. MATERIAL AND METHODS Forty patients (32 females and 8 males, the mean age 60.5 years) with distal radius fractures treated by internal fixation using volar surgical approach were involved in the study between 2013-2016. The tested subjects were randomized and split into two groups according to the selected method of rehabilitation. The tested subjects with standard rehabilitation extended with shoulder girdle muscles activation were labelled as group I. It included patients (n = 20) of the mean age 59.8 (age range 42-73 years) with immobilized wrist (i.e. for 3-4 weeks) performing shoulder girdle muscles exercises at the same time. Furthermore, standard kinesiotherapy continued after their fixation was removed. The other tested group, labelled as group II (n = 20), the mean age 61.3 (variation 40-74 years of age) involved patients with distal radius fractures. Only standard rehabilitation was performed in this group as late as their forearm fixation was removed. The following indices and parameters were assessed in the early postoperative period (i.e. by 8 weeks after the fixation removal): wrist and fingers range of motion (ROM), hand grip strength (dynamometry), local swelling, pain, scores of a nine hole peg test (NHPT), and a DASH score. RESULTS After the fixation had been removed, the group I reported statistically significantly higher values of movement compared to the values of the contralateral limb in the following directions: dorsal flexion, palmar flexion, MP joints flexion, flexion of PIP joints (proximal interphalangeal), and flexion of DIP joints (distal interphalangeal). After eight weeks, the group I manifested significantly higher values in dorsal flexion, palmar flexion and ulnar deviation in the wrist. There were no significant differences in other movement directions. The hand grip strength mean value examined with a dynamometer was significantly higher in the group I in the sixth and eighth week of testing (group I - 58.9% strength of a healthy limb after six weeks, or 66.5% after eight weeks). The results in the group II were 49.9% strength of a healthy limb after six weeks, or 56.6% after eight weeks. The group I showed statistically significantly lower values of wrist swelling and higher finger dexterity in the NHPT in all measured weeks. Lower pain intensity in the group I during the measurements was observed. At the same time, this group showed significantly better results in the DASH score. DISCUSSION The results of this study are useful for clinical practice. They confirm a functional relation between the activity of hand muscles and the shoulder muscle activity. The differences in the functional ability of the hand and the functional state of the injured wrist were detected as early as in the early postoperative period. It could be stated that the tested subjects in the group I showed a greater and faster improvement in the physical function of the injured hand. This was also accompanied by a positive psychological effect. We had not found a study of a similar type in the available literature that we could have compared our submitted results to. CONCLUSIONS Shoulder girdle muscles exercises after a distal radius fracture, while wrist is immobilized, can evidently enhance functional capability and accelerate the hand-function restitution. Early functional outcomes of the injured wrist after the rehabilitation with shoulder girdle muscles exercises support the efficiency of this broadened rehabilitation protocol. Key words: distal radius frac,ture, hand, shoulder, functional treatment, rehabilitation.
研究目的 本研究旨在评估桡骨远端骨折手术治疗患者术后早期康复的功能结局。我们将接受标准康复治疗的患者与术后康复通过在腕关节固定时对患侧上肢进行肩带锻炼而得以延长的患者组进行了比较。使用了几个指标和变量来评估患侧手腕的功能治疗结局。
材料与方法 2013年至2016年期间,纳入了40例采用掌侧手术入路内固定治疗的桡骨远端骨折患者(32例女性,8例男性,平均年龄60.5岁)。根据所选的康复方法将受试对象随机分为两组。接受标准康复并增加肩带肌肉激活训练的受试对象标记为I组。该组包括平均年龄59.8岁(年龄范围42 - 73岁)的患者(n = 20),其腕关节固定(即3 - 4周),同时进行肩带肌肉锻炼。此外,在去除固定后继续进行标准运动疗法。另一受试组标记为II组(n = 20),平均年龄61.3岁(年龄范围40 - 74岁),包括桡骨远端骨折患者。该组仅在去除前臂固定后进行标准康复治疗。在术后早期(即去除固定后8周)评估以下指标和参数:腕关节和手指的活动范围(ROM)、握力(测力计测量)、局部肿胀、疼痛、九孔插钉试验(NHPT)评分和DASH评分。
结果 去除固定后,I组在以下方向上报告的运动值与对侧肢体相比在统计学上显著更高:背伸、掌屈、掌指关节屈曲、近端指间关节(PIP)屈曲和远端指间关节(DIP)屈曲。八周后,I组在腕关节背伸、掌屈和尺偏方面表现出显著更高的值。在其他运动方向上没有显著差异。在测试的第六周和第八周,用测力计检查的握力平均值在I组显著更高(I组在六周后为健侧肢体力量的58.9%,八周后为66.5%)。II组的结果在六周后为健侧肢体力量的49.9%,八周后为56.6%。在所有测量周中,I组的腕关节肿胀值在统计学上显著更低,并且在NHPT中手指灵活性更高。在测量期间观察到I组的疼痛强度更低。同时,该组在DASH评分中显示出显著更好的结果。
讨论 本研究结果对临床实践有用。它们证实了手部肌肉活动与肩部肌肉活动之间的功能关系。早在术后早期就检测到了手部功能能力和受伤腕关节功能状态的差异。可以说,I组的受试对象在受伤手部的身体功能方面显示出更大且更快的改善。这还伴随着积极的心理效应。在现有文献中,我们未找到可将我们提交的结果与之比较的类似类型研究。
结论 桡骨远端骨折后,在腕关节固定时进行肩带肌肉锻炼可明显提高功能能力并加速手部功能恢复。通过肩带肌肉锻炼进行康复后,受伤腕关节的早期功能结局支持了这种扩展康复方案的有效性。
桡骨远端骨折,手,肩,功能治疗,康复