Thurber E T, Bass E P, Beckenhauer W H
Can J Comp Med. 1977 Apr;41(2):131-6.
Field trials were conducted using an experimental, modified live virus, oral vaccine for prevention of reo- and coronavirus calf diarrhea. Prior to the trials, one or both of the specific causative agents were identified from affected calves in each participating herd. In 21 herds, sequential trials were conducted in which results of uninterrupted vaccination were compared with disease rates during a preceding or subsequent control period. In these herds there was a statistically significant reduction in the morbidity and mortality from disease in 1,598 vaccinates compared with the rates in 829 prevaccination control calves. Morbidity and mortality in 206 post-vaccination control calves rose marginally above the rates in the same vaccinates. In 26 other herds, where double blind trials were conducted, rates of morbidity and mortality from disease were virtually the same for 1,080 vaccinated calves and 355 placebo calves. Vaccinates in the sequential trials had the lowest morbidity and mortality rates of any test group in either field trial format. In a selected dairy herd, both field trial formats were implemented and the results compared. In the double blind trial, vaccinates and placebo calves had comparable rates of morbidity and mortality from disease. When a sequential trial was later implemented, a statistically significant reduction in morbidity and mortality occurred in vaccinates compared with rates in control calves.
进行了田间试验,使用一种实验性的、改良活病毒口服疫苗来预防牛轮状病毒和冠状病毒引起的腹泻。在试验前,从每个参与试验的牛群中受感染的犊牛身上鉴定出一种或两种特定病原体。在21个牛群中进行了连续试验,将不间断接种疫苗的结果与之前或之后对照期的疾病发生率进行比较。在这些牛群中,1598头接种疫苗的犊牛的发病率和死亡率与829头接种疫苗前对照犊牛的发病率和死亡率相比,在统计学上有显著降低。206头接种疫苗后对照犊牛的发病率和死亡率略高于相同接种组的发病率和死亡率。在另外26个进行双盲试验的牛群中,1080头接种疫苗的犊牛和355头安慰剂犊牛的疾病发病率和死亡率几乎相同。在任何一种田间试验形式中,连续试验中的接种组发病率和死亡率都是所有试验组中最低的。在一个选定的奶牛场,两种田间试验形式都实施了,并对结果进行了比较。在双盲试验中,接种疫苗的犊牛和安慰剂犊牛的疾病发病率和死亡率相当。后来进行连续试验时,接种疫苗的犊牛的发病率和死亡率与对照犊牛相比在统计学上有显著降低。