Krishna Murali, Lepping Peter, Sharma Vimal K, Copeland John Rm, Lockwood Lorraine, Williams Margaret
Department of Psychiatry, Wrexham Maelor Hospital, North Wales NHS Trust, Wrexham, UK.
Clin Pract Epidemiol Ment Health. 2009 Apr 13;5:7. doi: 10.1186/1745-0179-5-7.
A computer assisted interview, the GMHAT/PC has been developed to assist General Practitioners and other Health Professionals to make a quick, convenient and comprehensive standardised mental health assessment. It has proved to be a reliable and valid tool in our previous studies involving General Practitioners and Nurses. Little is known about its use in cardiac rehabilitation settings.
The study aims to assess the feasibility of using a computer assisted diagnostic interview by nurses for patients attending Cardiac Rehabilitation Clinics and to examine the level of agreement between the GMHAT/PC diagnosis and a Psychiatrist clinical diagnosis. Prevalence of mental illness was also measured.
Cross sectional validation and feasibility study.
Nurses using GMHAT/PC examined consecutive patients presenting to a cardiac rehabilitation centre. A total of 118 patients were assessed by nurses and consultant psychiatrist in cardiac rehabilitation centres. The kappa coefficient (kappa), sensitivity, and specificity of the GMHAT/PC diagnosis were analysed as measures of validity. The time taken for the interview as well as feedback from patients and interviewers were indicators of feasibility. Data on prevalence of mental disorders in an outpatient cardiac rehabilitation setting was collected.
The mean duration of the interview was 14 minutes. Feedback from patients and interviewers indicated good practical feasibility. The agreement between GMHAT/PC interview-based diagnoses and consultant psychiatrists' ICD-10 criteria-based clinical diagnosis was good or excellent (kappa = 0.76, sensitivity = 0.73, specificity = 0.90). The prevalence of mental disorders in this group was 22%, predominantly depression. Very few cases were on treatment.
GMHAT/PC can assist nurses in making accurate mental health assessments and diagnoses in a cardiac rehabilitation setting and is acceptable to cardiac patients. It can successfully be used to gather epidemiological data and help in managing mental health problems in this group of patients.
已开发出一种计算机辅助访谈工具GMHAT/PC,以协助全科医生和其他健康专业人员进行快速、便捷且全面的标准化心理健康评估。在我们之前涉及全科医生和护士的研究中,它已被证明是一种可靠且有效的工具。关于其在心脏康复环境中的使用情况,人们了解甚少。
本研究旨在评估护士使用计算机辅助诊断访谈对心脏康复诊所患者的可行性,并检验GMHAT/PC诊断与精神科医生临床诊断之间的一致性水平。同时还测量了精神疾病的患病率。
横断面验证和可行性研究。
使用GMHAT/PC的护士对前来心脏康复中心的连续患者进行检查。共有118名患者在心脏康复中心接受了护士和精神科顾问医生的评估。分析GMHAT/PC诊断的kappa系数(kappa)、敏感性和特异性,作为有效性的衡量指标。访谈所需时间以及患者和访谈者的反馈是可行性指标。收集了门诊心脏康复环境中精神障碍患病率的数据。
访谈的平均时长为14分钟。患者和访谈者的反馈表明实际可行性良好。基于GMHAT/PC访谈的诊断与精神科顾问医生基于ICD - 10标准的临床诊断之间的一致性良好或极佳(kappa = 0.76,敏感性 = 0.73,特异性 = 0.90)。该组中精神障碍的患病率为22%,主要为抑郁症。接受治疗的病例极少。
GMHAT/PC可协助护士在心脏康复环境中进行准确的心理健康评估和诊断,并且心脏患者能够接受。它可成功用于收集流行病学数据,并有助于管理该组患者的心理健康问题。