Zviagin V N, Permiakova E Iu, Galitskaia O I
Sud Med Ekspert. 2009 Jan-Feb;52(1):43-5.
The study material was ribs of the Caucasoid carcasses from the collections of the Department of Anthropology, M.V. Lomonosov Moscow State University, and the Department of Personality Identification, Russian Centre of Forensic Medical Examination. Each rib was measured as stipulated by the 13 point program of A.I. Turovtsev (1972). The results were analysed with the use of the SPSS statistical packet. Diagnostic models were calculated for the purpose of forensic medicine practice based on step-by-step discriminative analysis. It is recommended to perform expert evaluation in two stages. The aim of the first stage, is to establish the group affiliation of a concrete rib. Group 1 comprises III-V ribs, group 2--ribs VI--VIII, and group 3--ribs IX-XI. Determination of the sequential localization of I, II, and XII ribs encounters practically no difficulty due to their unique anatomical structure. The accuracy of classication of group localization of the ribs amounts to 99.6%. At the second stage, individual number of a concrete rib within a group is determined. The accuracy of classification of ribs belonging to groups 1 and 3 is 80.2% and 85.7% respectively and that of ribs in group 2 is lightly lower (41.7-69%). Sexual identity of the ribs was determined by means of multidimensional discriminative analysis. The accuracy of diagnosis is directly related to the integrity of the study material; in other words, it depends on the amount of ribs available for the analysis. It is shown that sexual identity is best established for rib VI followed by ribs VIII, II, IV, and I respectively. The main discriminative features include the total arch length, costal plane curvature, and height-width dimension. Diagnostic equations are derived for the determination of sexual identity of individual ribs for the practical purposes of forensic medical examination.
研究材料取自莫斯科国立罗蒙诺索夫大学人类学系以及俄罗斯法医鉴定中心个人身份鉴定系收藏的高加索人种尸体的肋骨。每根肋骨均按照A.I. 图罗夫采夫(1972年)的13点程序进行测量。使用SPSS统计软件包对结果进行分析。基于逐步判别分析计算出用于法医学实践的诊断模型。建议分两个阶段进行专家评估。第一阶段的目的是确定某根具体肋骨所属的组。第1组包括第III - V肋,第2组为第VI - VIII肋,第3组为第IX - XI肋。由于第I、II和XII肋独特的解剖结构,确定它们的顺序定位实际上没有困难。肋骨组定位分类的准确率为99.6%。在第二阶段,确定某组内某根具体肋骨的个体编号。属于第1组和第3组的肋骨分类准确率分别为80.2%和85.7%,第2组肋骨的准确率略低(41.7 - 69%)。通过多维判别分析确定肋骨的性别特征。诊断的准确性与研究材料的完整性直接相关;换句话说,它取决于可用于分析的肋骨数量。结果表明,对第VI肋确定性别特征的效果最佳,其次分别是第VIII、II、IV和I肋。主要判别特征包括总弓长、肋平面曲率和高宽尺寸。为了法医学实践的实际目的,推导了用于确定个体肋骨性别的诊断方程。