Miller J F, Morahan G, Allison J, Hoffmann M
Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of Medical Research, Post Office Royal Melbourne Hospital, Victoria, Australia.
Immunol Rev. 1991 Aug;122:103-16. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-065x.1991.tb00599.x.
There is now convincing evidence for the imposition of self tolerance by means of the clonal deletion of self-reactive T cells operating within the thymus. Since not all self components may be encountered there, the question must be asked whether tolerance can occur post-thymically. To test this, we and other investigators have used transgenic technology to direct expression of a known "nonself" gene to a given extrathymic tissue. No lymphocytic infiltration was ever seen in transgene-expressing tissues, even if the mice were given normal syngeneic (nontransgenic) spleen cells intravenously or were stimulated with H-2Kb spleen cells. Infiltration did, however, occur in irradiated transgenic recipients of H-2Kb immune spleen cells. In MET-Kb mice, this infiltrate diminished with time, raising the possibility that peripheral tolerance may even have been induced in immune cells. H-2Kb-bearing skin was accepted in young RIP-Kb mice but rejected in older mice, which had lost more than 75% of their beta cells as a result of the overexpression of H-2Kb. This loss of tolerance thus occurred when the concentration of the tolerogen, H-2Kb, fell below some critical threshold. Following in vitro stimulation, spleen cells from young RIP-Kb mice could not kill H-2Kb-bearing targets, but could respond to third party targets. Thymus cells, on the other hand, could be stimulated to kill both targets, clearly indicating that tolerance was not imposed intrathymically. Spleen cells from older RIP-Kb mice (those that had lost most of their beta cells) killed both targets, which is in agreement with the in vivo data. Reactivity to H-2Kb was restored to young spleen cells by providing them with IL-2. Two hypotheses were proposed to account for the above findings: tolerance results either from the deletion or functional silencing of high-affinity effector cells or of regulatory, IL-2-producing helper T cells. As it is difficult to distinguish between these, we have produced a second series of transgenic mice (F3+) with rearranged TCR genes encoding an anti-H-2Kb TCR and derived "double-transgenic" (F3+RIP+) offspring by mating these mice with RIP-Kb mice. The transgenic TCR utilized the V beta 11 segment which can be detected by a monoclonal antibody. There were in the thymus very few CD4+ and very few CD4+8+ cells in both F3+ and F3+RIP+ mice and, in the double-transgenic mice, there was no evidence of deletion of CD8+V beta 11+ cells in the periphery although they showed tolerance to H-2Kb-bearing skin.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
现在有令人信服的证据表明,通过在胸腺内对自身反应性T细胞进行克隆清除来实现自身耐受。由于并非所有自身成分都能在胸腺中遇到,因此必须提出一个问题,即耐受是否能在胸腺外发生。为了验证这一点,我们和其他研究人员利用转基因技术将一个已知的“非自身”基因定向表达于特定的胸腺外组织。即使给小鼠静脉注射正常的同基因(非转基因)脾细胞或用H-2Kb脾细胞刺激,在转基因表达组织中也从未观察到淋巴细胞浸润。然而,在接受H-2Kb免疫脾细胞照射的转基因受体中确实发生了浸润。在MET-Kb小鼠中,这种浸润随时间减少,这增加了在免疫细胞中甚至可能诱导外周耐受的可能性。携带H-2Kb的皮肤在年轻的RIP-Kb小鼠中被接受,但在年老小鼠中被排斥,由于H-2Kb的过度表达,这些年老小鼠失去了超过75%的β细胞。当耐受原H-2Kb的浓度降至某个临界阈值以下时,就会出现这种耐受丧失。体外刺激后,年轻RIP-Kb小鼠的脾细胞不能杀死携带H-2Kb的靶细胞,但能对第三方靶细胞作出反应。另一方面,胸腺细胞可以被刺激杀死这两种靶细胞,这清楚地表明耐受不是在胸腺内施加的。年老RIP-Kb小鼠(那些失去了大部分β细胞的小鼠)的脾细胞杀死了这两种靶细胞,这与体内数据一致。通过为年轻脾细胞提供IL-2,恢复了它们对H-2Kb的反应性。提出了两种假说来解释上述发现:耐受要么源于高亲和力效应细胞或调节性、产生IL-2的辅助性T细胞的缺失或功能沉默。由于难以区分这两者,我们培育了第二系列转基因小鼠(F3+),其TCR基因重排,编码一种抗H-2Kb TCR,并通过将这些小鼠与RIP-Kb小鼠交配获得“双转基因”(F3+RIP+)后代。转基因TCR利用了Vβ11片段,可通过单克隆抗体检测到。在F3+和F3+RIP+小鼠的胸腺中,CD4+细胞很少,CD4+8+细胞也很少,并且在双转基因小鼠中,尽管它们对携带H-2Kb的皮肤表现出耐受,但在外周没有CD8+Vβ11+细胞缺失的证据。(摘要截短至400字)