De Bleser Leentje, Matteson Michelle, Dobbels Fabienne, Russell Cynthia, De Geest Sabina
Center for Health Services and Nursing Research, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Kapucijnenvoer 35/4, Leuven, Belgium.
Transpl Int. 2009 Aug;22(8):780-97. doi: 10.1111/j.1432-2277.2009.00881.x. Epub 2009 Apr 6.
Reports of interventions to improve adherence to medical regimens in solid organ transplant recipients are scarce. A systematic review identified 12 intervention studies. These studies focused on renal, heart, and liver transplant recipients. Five reports used randomized controlled trial (RCT) designs. Sample sizes varied between 18 and 110 subjects. The interventions are difficult to evaluate and categorize because of brief descriptions of intervention details. Of the 12 studies identified in this review, only five studies found a statistically significant improvement in at least one medication-adherence outcome with the intervention. In general, most included a combination of patient-focused cognitive/educational, counseling/behavioral, and psychologic/affective dimensions. Eight studies intervened at the healthcare provider, healthcare setting or healthcare system level, but showed a limited improvement in adherence. No single intervention proved to be superior at increasing medication-adherence in organ transplantation, but a combination of interventions in a team approach for the chronic disease management of organ transplant patients may be effective in a long-term perspective. In conclusion, finding the most effective combination of interventions to enhance adherence is vital. Utilizing an RCT design and adhering to the CONSORT guidelines can lead to higher quality studies and possibly more effective intervention studies to enhance medication-adherence.
关于改善实体器官移植受者对医疗方案依从性的干预措施的报告很少。一项系统综述确定了12项干预研究。这些研究聚焦于肾移植、心脏移植和肝移植受者。5份报告采用了随机对照试验(RCT)设计。样本量在18至110名受试者之间不等。由于对干预细节的描述简短,这些干预措施难以评估和分类。在本综述确定的12项研究中,只有5项研究发现干预措施至少在一项药物依从性结果上有统计学显著改善。总体而言,大多数研究包括以患者为中心的认知/教育、咨询/行为以及心理/情感方面的综合内容。8项研究在医疗服务提供者、医疗环境或医疗系统层面进行了干预,但在依从性方面改善有限。没有单一干预措施在提高器官移植中的药物依从性方面被证明更具优势,但从长期来看,采用团队方法对器官移植患者进行慢性病管理的综合干预措施可能有效。总之,找到最有效的干预措施组合以提高依从性至关重要。采用随机对照试验设计并遵循CONSORT指南可带来更高质量的研究,并可能开展更有效的干预研究以提高药物依从性。