Jahnz-Rózyk Karina, Targowski Tomasz, From Sławomir
Department of Immunology and Clinical Allergology, Central Clinical Hospital of the Ministry of National Defense, Military Institute of Health Services in Warsaw.
Pol Merkur Lekarski. 2009 Mar;26(153):208-14.
Exacerbations are the key drivers of the costs of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). This was the multicenter study of patients with COPD aimed at evaluating direct and indirect cost of exacerbations under usual clinical practice in primary and secondary care form societal perspective.
It was observational, multicenter study with participation of 196 subjects with moderate or severe COPD, defined according to the current GOLD criteria. Patients presenting at the selected health care centres were included into the study in the sequential manner if they fulfilled the inclusion criteria. Exacerbations were divided into three different severity types according to Anthonisen N.R. classification. The management of exacerbations followed the usual clinical practice.
The number of exacerbations was 3.8 (3.2-4.4) in hospitalised patients and 1.7 (1.4-1.9) in ambulatory treated patients (1EURO was 3.85 PLN in 2007). The average direct health-care cost per exacerbation was PLN 5548 (95% CI = 4543; 6502) and PLN 524.1 (95% CI = 443; 614) in secondary and primary care respectively. In secondary care, the drug acquisition and oxygen therapy cost represented 18.3% of total direct costs, diagnostic tests costs accounted for 14.5%, the other hospital care and post-discharge followup visit costs 67%. Costs varied considerably with the severity of COPD before the exacerbation as well as the duration of COPD. In primary care the cost structure was as follows: diagnostic tests and medical devices 47.5%, drug acquisition costs 41% and doctors visits 11.4%. The average indirect costs per exacerbation were PLN 127.78 and PLN 100.56, in secondary and primary respectively (n.s)
Exacerbations of COPD are costly. Cost of exacerbation managed in secondary care is almost 10-fold higher than in primary care. Prevention of moderate-to-severe exacerbations, requiring hospitalization could be very cost-effective strategy.
急性加重是慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)成本的关键驱动因素。这是一项针对COPD患者的多中心研究,旨在从社会角度评估在初级和二级医疗的常规临床实践中急性加重的直接和间接成本。
这是一项观察性多中心研究,有196名中度或重度COPD患者参与,根据当前的GOLD标准进行定义。如果符合纳入标准,在选定医疗中心就诊的患者按顺序纳入研究。根据安东尼森N.R.分类,急性加重分为三种不同的严重程度类型。急性加重的管理遵循常规临床实践。
住院患者的急性加重次数为3.8(3.2 - 4.4)次,门诊治疗患者为1.7(1.4 - 1.9)次(2007年1欧元等于3.85波兰兹罗提)。在二级医疗和初级医疗中,每次急性加重的平均直接医疗成本分别为5548波兰兹罗提(95%置信区间 = 4543;6502)和524.1波兰兹罗提(95%置信区间 = 443;614)。在二级医疗中,药品采购和氧疗成本占总直接成本的18.3%,诊断检查成本占14.5%,其他医院护理和出院后随访成本占67%。成本因急性加重前COPD的严重程度以及COPD的病程而有很大差异。在初级医疗中,成本结构如下:诊断检查和医疗设备47.5%,药品采购成本41%,医生诊疗11.4%。每次急性加重的平均间接成本在二级医疗和初级医疗中分别为127.78波兰兹罗提和100.56波兰兹罗提(无统计学差异)
COPD急性加重成本高昂。在二级医疗中管理急性加重的成本几乎比初级医疗高10倍。预防需要住院治疗的中度至重度急性加重可能是非常具有成本效益的策略。