Van Dijck Gert, Van Vaerenbergh Jo, Van Hulle Marc M
Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium.
Artif Intell Med. 2009 Jul;46(3):233-49. doi: 10.1016/j.artmed.2009.03.001. Epub 2009 May 5.
Assessing recovery after stroke has been so far a time consuming procedure in which trained clinicians are required. A demand for automated assessment techniques arises due to the increasing number of patients with stroke and the continuous growth of new treatment options. In this study, we investigate the applicability of isometric force and torque measurements in activity of daily living tasks to assess the functional recovery after stroke in an automated way.
A new hybrid filter-wrapper feature subset technology was developed for a new mechatronic platform with the aim to identify the most important features and sensors that can distinguish normal controls from patients with stroke. We compared 3 different classification algorithms to make the distinction: k-nearest neighbors, kernel density estimation and least-squares support vector machines. Based on isometric force and torque measurements obtained from 16 patients with a first-ever ischemic or haemorrhagic stroke within the middle cerebral artery territory, we computed for each subject the probability to belong to the class of normal subjects. These probabilities were computed during a period of 6 months post-stroke to quantify the level of recovery during this period. The posterior probabilities were validated by means of a correlation study with the Lindmark modified Fugl-Meyer assessment.
Patients with stroke and normal controls could be distinguished with an accuracy of 98.25% by means of kernel density estimation. The posterior probability profiles had a correlation of 76.6% and 80.29% with the global score of the Lindmark modified Fugl-Meyer scale and 'part A', the upper extremity subscore, respectively. This degree of correlation was as high as obtained with supervised scoring techniques such as the Barthel index.
This study shows that the assessment of recovery after stroke can be automated by means of posterior probability profiles due to their high correlation with the Fugl-Meyer assessment. The posterior probability profiles confirm the importance of a recovery within the first weeks after stroke to obtain a higher recovery plateau compared to later changes in recovery.
迄今为止,评估中风后的恢复情况是一个耗时的过程,需要训练有素的临床医生。由于中风患者数量的增加以及新治疗选择的不断涌现,对自动化评估技术的需求应运而生。在本研究中,我们调查了等长力和扭矩测量在日常生活活动任务中的适用性,以自动评估中风后的功能恢复情况。
为一个新的机电一体化平台开发了一种新的混合滤波器-包装器特征子集技术,旨在识别能够区分正常对照组和中风患者的最重要特征和传感器。我们比较了3种不同的分类算法来进行区分:k近邻算法、核密度估计和最小二乘支持向量机。基于从中脑动脉区域首次发生缺血性或出血性中风的16名患者获得的等长力和扭矩测量结果,我们为每个受试者计算了属于正常受试者类别的概率。这些概率在中风后的6个月内进行计算,以量化该期间的恢复水平。通过与林德马克改良Fugl-Meyer评估的相关性研究对后验概率进行了验证。
通过核密度估计,中风患者和正常对照组的区分准确率可达98.25%。后验概率曲线与林德马克改良Fugl-Meyer量表的总分以及上肢子量表“A部分”的相关性分别为76.6%和80.29%。这种相关程度与Barthel指数等监督评分技术所获得的相关程度一样高。
本研究表明,由于中风后恢复情况的评估与Fugl-Meyer评估具有高度相关性,因此可以通过后验概率曲线实现自动化评估。后验概率曲线证实了中风后第一周内恢复的重要性,与后期恢复变化相比,这有助于获得更高的恢复平台期。